Burnt aparagus, no problem
Miscommunications. Misinformation. Misunderstandings. Missing the mark. Could it be that this is how culture evolves. If cuisine is a paradigm, as I believe it is, then the answer is yes. By getting a recipe wrong, by not understanding what it's all about, we create a new dish, a new chunk of culture.
Take the Iberian soups that crossed the Atlantic to become the bean stews we pour over white rice in the Spanish Caribbean. They are not the namesake soups one can consume in Spain. Here they acquired a different character, not always because a cook was innovating, but possibly because something got lost -- and something gained -- in translation.
Long ago in Cuba, my mother would make filet mignon out of a Cuban cookbook. The beef was completely overcooked but the wine and onion sauce was delicious, and, in truth, the overcooked beef was delicious too. Of course, when my mother makes filet now, she leaves it medium rare and skips the sauce. But she does serve it with a mix of mashed potato and malanga, which improves on regular mashed potatoes.
Italian restaurants in Miami are actually Italian-Latin American restaurants, run by Italian immigrants to Latin countries -- or their children -- who became immigrants again to the U.S. Some find fault in this cooking, and, not knowing Italian cuisine in depth, I don't feel qualified to judge. But others have told me they prefer this variant of Italian cuisine over what more "authentic" Italian restaurants serve. Not to mention that the latter are no longer Italian since they are no longer in Italy. There is always creolization.
Chili con carne, is it a bastardization of Mexican cooking or a wonderful Texan invention? (I won't even get into tofu burritos.) Or pizza. Or frankfurters outside Frankfurt. Hamburgers outside Hamburg. English muffins outside England.
A couple of decades ago a half-French girlfriend of mine escorted a French filmmaker around New York during that city's film festival. What did this Parisian most love about New York? Croissants stuffed with marmalade -- like jelly doughnuts. They didn't have such wonders back in France. Had he come to Miami, he could've sampled them stuffed with guava marmalade. Croissants cubanos.
As much of an authenticity nut as I am, I also have to acknowledge that if everything remained authentic nothing would change. Some times no change is good (isn't that the heart of conservative political thinking?). But change is inevitable. And it often happens -- in everything from evolution to cuisine -- by misfirings. By mistakes.
Wandering into 44, the restaurant at the boutique hotel The Royalton in Manhattan when it first opened, I noticed something like "blackened asparagus" (perhaps it just said "seared") on the menu. I thought, the kitchen burned the damn asparagus and just came up with a hip name to cover up their boo-oboo. "Those trendoids will eat anything,'' the chef might have said.
Perhaps. I ate it. And loved it.
Posted by Enrique Fernández at 06:24 PM on October 30, 2007 in Food and Drink | Permalink | Comments (1) | TrackBack (0)

