A while back I wrote a Consumed column on taking my daughter, then going on 12, to a "grownup" restaurant. I deliberately picked one that would take liberties with dishes -- the casual nuevo Latino restaurant Chispa. And I did not bring her older brother so she would be the only truly young person at the table.
Now, I though it was time to take the young man, who is 15, to an even more sophisticated spot. Not that he does not dine out; in fact, he was asking me to take him to a restaurant. Plus he enjoys the pleasures of a good table, good service and a fine menu. But so far our forays have been into places where some kind of traditional food is served. It was time to reach higher.
"This is the hottest spot in town,'' I told him as we walked into Michy's (6927 Biscayne Blvd
Miami, FL 33138; 305-759-2001). "And the chef, Michelle Bernstein, the most celebrated in South Florida." I wanted to let him know we was getting bang for our (well, my) buck.
Because we did not have a reservation we had a wait -- it was a Wednesday, right after New Year's, and I did not expect a crowd, but a crowd there was, proof that, indeed, it was a hot spot. We sat outside, by a heater that kept us warm during the recent cold spell, and I asked for a glass of Pinot Noir and something to snack on. "Some croquetas?", the waiter suggested. I agreed. When they came, the croquetas were light as a feather -- the opposite of the thick, starchy, but addictive missiles one gets at Cuban coffee counters -- and the inside was mostly a melted cheese. I dug into them, but number 3 son (two much older brothers from my earlier life) was not impressed. "They're not croquetas,'' he said. "They're cheese sticks." That almost ruined it for me as I realized that, yes, they were cheese sticks, albeit heavenly ones.
Inside, he expressed a desire for meat and when he heard about the ribs, he jumped on them. I explained that it would not be a rack of barbecue, but short ribs, with meat falling off the bone. He pronounced them only "OK" when he ate them. I had ordered an appetizer of American country ham, sliced paper thin, like serrano or prosciutto, which we both liked. I had a half-order of sweetbreak cutlet for my main course; it was lovely, but then I'm a sweetbread fan. My dinner companion passed on tasting it, saving room for dessert, which I, lacking his adolescent metabolism, do not indulge in -- I get fat enough without sweets.
Considering the dessert menu, he ordered a cuatro leches, Michy's take on what is now a classic Miami evolution of the Nicaraguan tres leches. At first, he was skeptical, but when he really dug in, he became more enthusiastic.
Still, my son was underwhelemed by the experience. Perhaps it was because Michy's has moved beyond the New Cooking expected of fine restaurants into the earthier dishes that forward-looking chefs like Bernstein are returning to. In other words, the food was not fancy enough to impress a young person. Nor was it traditional enough to feel like a young person's comfort food. Maybe to dig that groove one has to have traveled with American cuisine to its present settings.
There was a big "cowboy steak" special, and I realized we should've split that. Or maybe the lad would've devoured it by himself. Food is culture and culture takes a while to settle in. Taking a younger generation out to dinner is instructive because expectations are different. Of course, there are also individual differences. But age has something to do with it. And there are always surprises. In any case, the tabula rasa of a younger palate makes one reconsider one's preferences. Am I overly impressed by a chef's and a restaurant's reputations? Do I give high points to cultural developments I approve of? How much of what I taste is really taste, in the purse sense of flavor, or taste, in the sense of how my tastes have evolved? I would've given Michy's at least 3 stars. My son, two if that. Neither one of us holds the truth.