« Would any team yield a high pick for Brown? | Main | Salary cap numbers from around the NFL »

The NFL (mock) draft as beat writers see it

Jimmy Johnson used to spend hours reading mock drafts as part of his draft-day preparations. He used to say that some of the most accurate tidbits of information he got on what other teams were likely to do came from the beat writers that covered those teams.

And that's the reason he used to go so far as to call certain beat writers or journalists in various cities to pick their brains about their teams.

What follows is an wealth of information and opinion Johnson would love to have were he still making picks in this draft. Below you will find a mock draft compiled with the cooperation of two dozen beat writers and columnists that cover the NFL in the 32 NFL cities.

Every team's information is compiled by that team's beat writer or columnist, most of whom got on a conference call Tuesday and conducted a draft as if it were happening in real time.

This is the result. Some interesting things come out of this. Notice Percy Harvin is not picked in the first round. Notice the Dolphins have their choice of several outstanding players with the selection, made by me, perhaps surprising based on how this mock played out.

Anyway, won't keep you any longer. Have at it. And in the comments section, you tell me if the Dolphins would actually pick the player I picked based on his, shall we say, interesting sense of humor as seen in this youtube video below.

1. DETROIT: (8 picks, 2 in first, 2 in third, 2 in sixth.) Needs: QB, DT, OT/G, entire defense. Comment: Leos were last in the league in defense, 30th in rushing. As of today, they have narrowed choice to three players - Matthew Stafford, Jason Smith and Aaron Curry. Scott McEwen, protege of Ron Hughes in Pittsburgh, runs the college operation as he has in the past. Pick: Everything points to Stafford. Lions have one Pro Bowl appearance in the last 51 years by a QB, that being Greg Landry in 1971.

2. ST. LOUIS: (7 picks) Needs: OT, WR. Comment: Cut two seven-time Pro Bowlers in Orlando Pace and Torry Holt for cap reasons. Have lost 27 of last 32 games. No. 2 overall for second year in a row. It's down to 4 players: Matt Sanchez, Eugene Monroe, Jason Smith and Curry. They have just one bona fide OT on roster in Alex Barron. Donnie Avery is their most experienced WR on the roster (53 career catches). It won’t be Sanchez. If they have a higher grade on Curry, they’ll take him. PICK: Eugene Monroe, OT, Virginia.

3. KANSAS CITY: (7 picks; no second, 2 in seventh) Needs: Pass rusher, LB, Speed WR, OT. Comment: The Chiefs had just 10 sacks last year, will be going to some 3-4 so there’s a LB need. They added Zach Thomas, Mike Vrabel and Monty Beisel to get them through this year at LB. PICK: OT Jason Smith, Baylor. If St. Louis goes Smith, they go Monroe.

4. SEATTLE: (10 picks, 4 in seventh) Needs: OLB, OT, QB, WR depth, S. Comment: LT Walter Jones is coming off microfracture surgery. QB Matt Hasselbeck missed nine games last year with a back injury. PICK: Aaron Curry, LB, Georgia Tech. Crabtree is an outside shot. 'Hawks like Jason Smith a bit better than Monroe.

5. CLEVELAND: (5 picks, 2 in 2nd, no 3rd, no 5th, no 7th) Needs: Pass rusher, 3-4 OLB, S, WR, RB. Comment: Mangini wants to overhaul the roster. He wants to trade and collect picks. We believe the Braylon Edwards trade will happen when they go on the clock on draft day. They will trade QB Brady Quinn if they can. The Browns are interested in Matt Sanchez, but the suspicion is they would trade down instead. The PICK: Mark Sanchez, QB, USC. The suspicion is they’ll take the WR with the pick they get from the Edwards deal. But guessing Crabtree would not be crazy.

6. CINCINNATI: (11 picks, 2 3rds, 2 in 6th, 3 in 7th) Needs: OT, C, WR, RB depth, pass rusher. Comment: At OT, Levi Jones has been injury prone, Stacy Andrews lost in free agency. They are happy with Anthony Collins at OT. If both top tackles are gone, the PICK: Andre Smith, OT, Alabama. They had him in for a meeting a week ago. Brian Orakpo is a possibility. Michael Crabtree is possible.

7. OAKLAND: (5 picks; no fifth, no sixth) Needs: WR, OT, S. It’s always about speed with the Raiders. They have nobody for Russell to throw to. They’re happy with run game. PICK: Jeremy Maclin, WR, Missouri. Michael Crabtree, WR, Texas Tech. They may like Maclin and Hayward-Bey. Michael Huff is on the trade block, we think.

8. JACKSONVILLE: (9 picks; 3 in seventh). Needs: WR, DT, S, OT, 3rd CB. Comment: They got Torry Holt, but they’re still hurting at WR. Dennis Northcutt and Mike Walker are their other two WRs. DT is a need since they dealt Marcus Stroud. Haven’t been able to play the type of D they like – clog the middle. The plan is to take the best player available. PICK: B.J. Raji, DT, Boston College.

9. GREEN BAY: (9 picks; 2 in third, 2 in sixth). Needs: Going 3-4. Could use DE, LB, OT, RB, S, DB. Comment: GM Ted Thompson has traded down 13 times in his first four drafts. In this scenario, they would trade down. PICK: Michael Crabtree, WR, Texas Tech. Their current D-line is: Jolley-Pickett-Jenkins. So Raji or Tyson Jackson are perfect fits. Not sure how they feel about Oher. The other 3 tackles would fit. Malcolm Jenkins would be an outside shot.

10. SAN FRANCISCO: (9 picks, 2 in fifth, 2 in seventh). Needs: OT, edge rusher, WR. Comment: They’re content to go with the QBs they have instead of taking one in the first round. They could use a RT. Singletary wants to go strictly to a 3-4 defense. PICK: Michael Oher, OT, Mississippi.

11. BUFFALO: (9 picks, 2 in first, 2 in fourth). Needs: DE, T, TE, LB. Comment:They can get a TE in the second round, and I can’t see them taking Pettigrew this early. A wild card would be Cushing. PICK: Brian Orakpo, DE, Texas. If he’s gone, take Robert Ayers or Aaron Maybin.

12. DENVER: (10 picks; 2 in first, 2 in third, 1 in fifth, 2 in seventh). Needs: Going 3-4 so NT, OLB, ILB, DE, WR. Comment: We’re suspecting defense in the first round for sure. QB is the riddle. If they pick a QB, they’ve basically admitted they screwed up in trading Cutler. Can’t see that. There might be some interest in Quinn. PICK: Tyson Jackson, DE, LSU.  Shanahan ran 14 drafts, they have 3 No. 1s from those drafts and only 2 are starters – DJ Williams and Ryan Clady.

13. WASHINGTON: (5 picks; no second, no fourth). Needs: pass rusher, OLB, RT. Comment: After this, they don’t pick again until No. 80. They traded second for Jason Taylor. Jason Campbell’s contract is up after this year. They would want Sanchez. The would have taken Orakpo or Tyson Jackson. They like the So. Cal linebackers. They have a tendency to take big-school players from SEC. Larry English is possible, but he’s from a small school. PICK: Larry English, DE, Northern Illinois. They’re not big on Maybin. They would consider a trade-down here.

14. NEW ORLEANS: (4 picks; 1st, 2 fourths, 7th). Needs: S, DE, CB, RB. Comment: They run a standard 4-3, Maybin or E. Brown are outside candidates. PICK: Malcolm Jenkins, FS, Ohio State. If he fits at safety, that’s fine with them.

15. HOUSTON: (8 picks; 2 in fourth) Needs: OLB, RB, FS are top three needs. Comment: They will try like crazy to trade back and take Matthews a bit later. PICK: Brian Cushing, LB, Southern Cal. It’s Cushing or Matthews unless Jenkins were to fall.

16. SAN DIEGO: (8 picks, no 2nd, three in fourth). Needs: DE, ILB, ROLB, S. Comment: They would like to take Tyson Jackson, DE. If Jackson gone, PICK: Beanie Wells, RB, Ohio State. If Wells gone, take Rey Maualuga. If all three gone, pass. Just kidding. Knowshon Moreno. (Running back is more of a future need that could be addressed now if the right guy is there.)

17. N.Y. JETS: (6 picks; no fifth) Needs: WR, QB, DE, RB. Comment:  Kellen Clemens and Brett Ratliff, are the current QBs. The value here is QB Josh Freeman of Kansas State. Pick: Freeman. Illinois CB Vontae Davis is possible.

18. DENVER: (from Chicago) (see picks above). Comment: They need defense. PICK: Clay MATTHEWS, OLB. Other option is Peria Jerry.

19. TAMPA BAY: (8 picks, no second, 3 sevenths) Needs: D-line, CB, WR. Comment: In total overhaul mode, new head coach, new GM, new coordinators, new QB, no Derrick Brooks. Jim Bates is veering from Tampa 2. PICK: Peria Jerry, DT, Mississippi.

20. DETROIT: (from Dallas) (See picks above). Needs: Defense. Comment:  The Lions would take Jerry. Lions worst in NFL in rushing defense. Saints converted 11 straight third downs vs. them late last season. Horrible. PICK: Ziggy Hood, DT, Missouri.

21. PHILADELPHIA: (10 picks; no 4th. four in fifth, two in sixth). Needs: RB, Interior OL, TE, WR, DE. Comment: Already traded away a pick for Jason Peters of Buffalo. PICK: Knowshon Moreno, RB, Georgia. Brian Westrbook about to turn 30 has balky knee.

22. MINNESOTA: (6 picks; no 4th, no 6th, 2 in seventh). Needs: RT, WR, CB, DT, C. Comment: RT is Ryan Cook, second round in 2006. WR need a second guy. Winfield is over 30 at corner. Need more bodies there. QB – they seem to be content with Rosenfels and Travaris Jackson. They like all the OTs. PICK: Eben Britton, OT, Arizona, Also: Harvin or Haywood-Bey are possible.

23. NEW ENGLAND: (11 picks; 3 in second, 2 in third; 2 in sixth). Needs: More pass rush, S, CB, LB. Comments: Six picks in the first 97 as rich get richer. Belichick said it’s the most flexibility he’s ever had. Expect them to move up and down. Defense was 26th on third down. PICK: Robert Ayers, DE, Tennessee. Belichick loves the height weight guys. He also likes the UConn cornerback Darius Butler.

24. ATLANTA: (7 picks, 2 in fifth, no 7th). Needs: OLB, SS, TE, CB. The PICK: Brandon Pettigrew, TE Oklahoma State. They like Larry English. However, in this scenario, Aaron Maybin would be a strong consideration.

25. MIAMI: (9 picks; 2 in second, 2 in seventh). Needs: Starting CB, No. 1 WR, pass rushers. Comment: The Dolphins won’t be afraid to take the best player available. CB Will Allen is one starter. They signed mediocre CB Eric Green; They do not have a No. 1 WR in their popgun offense. They want more pass-rush help for 32-year-old Joey Porter, who had 43 percent of their sacks. Everybody’s talking about Virginia’s LB Clint Sintim because he played with Al Groh, but he’s a second-round pick. (If somebody real good falls - Clay Matthews, Rey Maualuga or even Moreno, they'll pick him based on value. Pick: Rey Maualuga, LB, USC. Second choice: Darius Butler, CB, UConn. Third choice: WR Hakeem Nicks. Fourth choice: WR Kenny Britt.

26. BALTIMORE: (6 picks, no 7th). Needs: TE, OT, WR, Comment: Must help young QB Joe Flacco and Cam Cameron will be crying for more help on offense. The PICK: Aaron Maybin, DE, Penn State. Visited them. They could use Pettigrew. Feel free to flip-flop Maybin to Atlanta and Pettigrew to Baltimore in this mock draft.

27. INDIANAPOLIS: (8 picks; 2 in fourth). Needs: WR, DT, OLB, RB, OT. Comment: Marvin Harrison is gone but may still be re-signed if Colts don't find a replacement in the draft. Oh, too bad, they do find a replacement. PICK: Darrius Hayward-Bey, WR, Maryland. A fallback pick would be: Brian Robiskie, WR, Ohio State.

28. BUFFALO: (from Carolina & Philly) (picks see above). PICK: Phil Loadholt, OT, Oklahoma. Fills need for a starting right tackle.

29. N.Y. GIANTS: (10 picks; 2 in second, 2 in third, 2 in fifth). Needs: WR, OT, MLB. Comment: Toomer cut, Plaxico Burress is gone. In this scenario, the PICK: Hakeem Nicks, WR, North Carolina. They checked out Kenny Britt, but he didn’t have a great workout.

30. TENNESSEE: (10 picks, 2 in fourth, 2 in sixth, 2 in seventh). Needs: WR, CB, OLB, OT. Comment: Best player available is in play here. Pick: Kenny Britt, WR, Rutgers. A very good option for them would be CB Alphonso Smith. They would pass on Harvin due to off the field issues.

31. ARIZONA: (8 picks, 2 in 7th). Needs: RB, OLB, TE. Comment: Expected to release Edgerrin James, three of their OLBs are over 30 and have had injuries. They’ve been searching for a TE for 2 decades. PICK: Donald Brown, RB UConn. They’re high on Larry English, think he’s a great kid and a hard worker.

32. PITTSBURGH: (9 picks, 2 in fifth, 2 in seventh). Needs: OL depth, DL depth, CB depth. Comments: Steelers love picking here and would love to do it every year. PICK: DL Fili Moala, USC. Options are C Alex Mack or C Eric Wood.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The NFL (mock) draft as beat writers see it:


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

dfan must be a racist

Monkey. I didn't have Dfan because he is a azzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz.

mr bunglito, can dfan use his azzzzz in football ?

i think if this mock was right up to the 25th we would take everett brown the DE from FSU b/c rey has character issues and we need pass rush and brown is a great pass rusher
but i hope we'll get sean smith, if we have the opportunity and don't get him ill be pissed
also if gort falls to us he'll be a sure thing b/c the tuna wants someone around his weight out there and he's a versatile beast

the format of this post is too confusing, or I'm too tired, or something/ w/ever, I can't follow it,.

Over At gorts home planet, bill (531 lb tuna)parcells is a runt.

Bunglito is a little whimpy azzzzzzzzzzzzzz

Hey gopats,

Just tell that bozo where you were born so he can get over it. I guess with a name like gopats you are from the country of jedzrak(jetsrock).

Yeeeeeeesssss it's bart or is it fart ? what a azzzzzzzzzzzzz.

Yessssssssss it's Bunglito or foolito. Why do you always talk like a retard. Kinda gay, not that there is anything wrong with that.

Kaiser ( aka ? ). so there's nothing wrong with being gay , but you throw the word "Retard " around like it's nothing. what a azzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz. good movie by the way , but you're still a Fooooolito azzzzzzzzzzzz.

Who's the fins gonna pick???, shoot the "Q" at the menace, the menace is on line the time is 12:09...


Use correct English..You are an azzzzzzz, not you are a azzzzzzzzz. No speaky english?

Guy's quit talking about azzzzz's... please....

Got stuff your face with more hot dogs you azzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz.

I had you going in the 1st round. What do you think ?

Lets talk about Gort, 7 ft 6 in. 785lbs, this guy's a monster(well actually a robot) i say fins need to move up to get the gortster, what are your thoughts... it's 12:23 am and your with the cuban. its 48 degrees here in the city so great they named it twice, shoot a "Q" at the menace...


You said "Guys quit talking..."
I know I am a guy. Is Bunglito a guy if he is gay? Just asking.

Great "Q" kobayashi, can i ask a "Q" to you my friend, judging by your name your from the far east, what is the price of tuna going for in japan?? and no i don't believe that bungalito is gay , but might be curious??? Its 12:30 and your with the menace...

Not that there's anything wrong with that...

A so..Menace...Tuna go for 200,000 yen. Ichi ni san shi You right about Bunglito.. name means little bung as in hole. He cannot be gay or his bung would be huge. Domo Arigato

Maybe Bunglito like to give to other men. We shall call him Oralito. Rei

Great observation my asian friend, again the I.Q level that the Orients possess is far greater then ours...Well your people be able to help us out of this financial quagmire we're in????

If either Rey or Maybin is there have no doubts one will be choosen BUT the odds are slim to none that either is going to be there even slimmer is wr is the choice at 25

All mock drafts are rediculous, not just this one. Nobody can predict what player goes where from top 2 bottom. Also, all you Harvin haters are really ignorant. Yeah, I agree, he messed up, but he would be a steal for the Dolphins if we got him. He's the perfect guy for the Wildcat. I'm a diehard Gators and Fins fan and I would love to get Percy. He never had off field issues in college, so this weed matter will most likely not be a future problem!

Agree Blaze, It's 12:55 and your with the menace, Who else has a "Q" for the Cuban tonite??

I think harvin and ricky williams would make great weedmates.... I'am sorry team mates..

Jason. First learn how to spell ( rediculous ? ) before you call people ignorant. Harvin has had off the field issues dating all the way back to high school. Who are you kidding ? He has an attitude problem . Miami should have nothing to do with this FOOL.

Cuban, I have a series of questions for you. I think Hakeem Nicks is good and all, but where was he before Brandon Tate was injured? Is it me, or did he only have one good season? Do you think he is hyped up a little to much?

I would like our first pick to be on the defensive side of the ball. I don't care if it is an lb or cb.

Sosa, picking a w.r is always a tricky, like Forrest gump said about a box of chocolate rings true to picking a wide out " You never know what you'll get" with that being said i think 2 of the guys on the team are "a" Lister's and 1 of them is not.(guess which one is not) so i say pick a D line man or a C.Back, they cant go wrong with that.. but then again it's only a opinion

O.K kids the menaces time on line has come to an end, see you guys tommarrow, till then may the phins pick correct and win at least 10 games next year.. they'll need to... peace guys...

The Menace from Cuba, Do you think it is true what the other blogger says that the Dolphins will trade Ronnie Brown for the Eagles cb? I do not believe it, and think it would be a sad, dark day in Dolphins history. And the 700 lb Tuna wouldn't let that happen on draft day.

Eagles Cb and a second rounder I think he said actually, still a very sad, dark day for the Dolphins if that liar wasn't lying.

Dont know Sosa, hate to see ronnie go but his contract ends at the end of the year and i dont think the phins will be able to afford him, not only that but the fins have a couple good back ups, so i'am thinking get something now for him( maybe a 2nd rounder ) but i think his tour of duty with the fish is about to end, so i wish Mr. brown good luck in his new endeavors..

DE, OLB or CB for their first pick. WR, CB or OLB for their second pick. I don't see them taking an ILB when they resigned Crowder and started Ayodele last year with Super Bowl champion Torbor as a back up. Those three are all solid, young veteran ILBs. There is no need to take a ILB that high. Maybe for depth and special teams late in the draft if they are presented with the right guy. DT would also be a consideration with their first three picks. With this mock, however, I say Butler, CB from UCONN, is their pick.

Mando, you've given me new found hope!!!

I've always wanted Maualuga to slide to us but based on a more realistic scenario, my 2nd choice is Nicks. If Rey Rey does slide to us, you will be my hero for reinspiring me to hope for that to happen ...and a genius!!!

Only problem is... if I'm wishing for him to not get picked by each team, it's gonna be a long, gutwrenching, nervewracking 1st round. But being a Dolphin fan has conditioned me for moments like this. So let's bring it on!!

2 MORE DAYS BABY!!! Heres hoping the trifecta hit a trifecta!!!

I like your picks. They fill the needs and if the players are available, it would be the second draft in a row that we did things that make sense.

please, don't sign Jason tylor of the past .we must look at the future

Oh yeah...

If, I repeat if, by some twist of fate Maualuga is our 1st rd pick then if (although I sincerely doubt it) Britt is there at 2b we should scoop him up.

More realistically, if we have to wait a little, I like this kid Johnny Knox. He's a burner, great route runner, and has excellent hands. The trifecta also had him in 2 or 3 times which tells you something. He's a little light. I'm sure they checked out his strength and ability to beat press coverage.

PS: With Sean Smith likely gone in the 2nd, Alphonso Smith looks good. He's small but does nothing but make plays. His picks are off the charts.

i love you menace ,where were you born ?

you have to be a realist ... prob clay matthews or kenny britt.

please dont sign taylor i second that .. Me and my life partner ace have come to the conclusion that he will stunt our d's growth.

Dear Kobayashi,

The Menace was born in a little hut in Rio De La Enchilada Grande, Cuba.
He started off with only the clothes on his back and a bongo drum.
But through perserverance, a strong will to live and burning desire to eat, he was able to make his way to The Big City by constructing a makeshift wooden raft out of palm tree bark. Brilliant!! ...The rest is history!

aqua 1, ilove you man,whare were you born ?

Aqua 1, could'nt have wrote a better biography brother, kudos to you...

Gary, we will sign JT even if we have to trade ronnie .don't you love jason the way he plays ?


koba i lost all respect for u after i saw this video of u getting beat like a meat freind.

please explain.

some how ,some what aqua 1 and cuban menace are here the same time,put the bottle down menace

i love jason physically but ace is so persuasive and that has a big role in my opinion but deep inside d fan i would love to see jason in those white and aqua pants again.


Carlito, see aqua 1s post at 8:27

joey deville , why you lost respect for me, i want jason back and trade ronnie if it's ok with you.joey, where were you born ?

are you aqua 1 ,cuban menace or you guys are close friends ?where aqua 1 was born ?

im from hollis queens..

carlito u dont spit in the face of people who dont want to be cool do u?

Worst Draft Memories

Eddie Moore
John Avery
Eric Kumerow.

no way everette brown falls out of the 1st round...fins would take him before rey rey....


If Maualuga is there, they've got to take him. However tempting it might be to take Nicks, they should resist if they can get Harvin in the 2nd round.

« 1 2 3 4 »

The comments to this entry are closed.