On January 15, 2000, Dan Marino played his final game for the Miami Dolphins, ending an 17-year era of unprecendented and unbelievable quarterback play for the franchise.
Tonight, more than a decade after Marino threw his final pass, the Dolphins will hand their offense's reins to the 15th different starting quarterback since Marino. Yes, after a decade and so many starters and so many failures, the Dolphins are still looking for the franchise quarterback to succeed the franchise's all-time best quarterback.
Tyler Thigpen is the man under center tonight against the Chicago Bears.
Dolphins fans are optimistic. They're excited about what Thigpen might bring to the team, if comments on this blog and phone calls to my Armando and the Amigo radio show are any measure. Folks are expectant because Thigpen has shown an ability and desire to throw down the field and salvage bad plays with his running and scrambling.
So we shall see whether those optimistic expectations are realized.
Me? I've seen all those post-Marino QBs come, and go, and mostly fail. So 'm a little cautious about expecting great things anymore. I've been disappointed too many times.
Consider the list of successors:
Jay Fiedler (2000-2004): He was gritty and as much a winner as one could hope. But he simply didn't have the arm of an elite QB and the Dolphins never really gave him a star receiver to work with. He got beat up a lot and played hurt a lot. So after five years, a battered Fiedler moved on.
Damon Huard (1999-2000): Jimmy Johnson loved him. Dave Wannstedt didn't. Huard was a fine deep thrower and did well at avoiding mistakes. But he seemed to operate just a tad slow for the NFL when he was here and never anchored himself as a starter anywhere else, either. Good backup, however.
Ray Lucas (2001-2002): Great guy. Great confidence. Then he threw that first, second, third, and fourth interception, and suffered that first and second fumble. And it happened in one meltdown game against Buffalo. There went the confidence. Lucas started six games for the Dolphins in 2002 and while he was never as bad as he was in that first game, he was never really good. He was gone after that season.
Brian Griese (2003): He had a good year or two in Denver before falling out of favor. And once the Broncos recognized he could not be the next John Elway, the Dolphins soon realized he also was not the next Marino. I remember sitting in Rick Spielman's office and him showing me film of Griese getting rid of the ball way early because he seemed unwilling to take hits. It didn't help the offensive line Spielman constructed for the Dolphins was not too good at that point.
Sage Rosenfels (2004-2005): He was a solid looking player but never more than a backup. That's the way it was and remains today.
A.J. Feeley (2004): Everything Fiedler had in the leadership dept., Feeley lacked during his Dolphins days. He would complain that Miami's offense was not as good as Philadelphia's West Coast scheme. He also threw a lot of interceptions and that made the second round pick the Dolphins gave for him a waste. He lasted only one preseason when Nick Saban arrived. Saban didn't have much use for losers.
Gus Frerotte (2005): Another great guy. He had an OK season (18 TDs, 13 ints, 52 percent completion) during Saban's first year. But everyone, including Saban, knew Frerotte was a backup working as a starter. After the season, Saban went quarterback shopping. He offered Frerotte a backup contract and no shot to start. That offended Frerotte so he left town as a free agent.
Daunte Culpepper (2006-2007): An interesting guy, to say the least. He had this love-hate relationship with the media, and his coaches and the organization. First time I met him, he told me he expected to throw at least 30 TDs for the Dolphins in the 2006 season. Didn't quite work out. The knee he had shredded with the Vikings the year before was not completely healed in 2006, although the Dolphins thought it was -- until the regular season began and Culpepper couldn't get out of his own way. Then he got into that expletive-filled argument with Saban during a practice. Then he got benched. Then Saban left. Then Cam Cameron was hired and he had no intention of keeping Culpepper on his team.
Joey Harrington (2006): Smart guy. A little goofy. Very enthusiastic with coaches. Not much respected by teammates. I admit, when I saw Harrington play in the Fiesta Bowl, he made one throw about 30 yards down the seam -- a rope to a tight end over an unsuspecting linebacker's helmet -- that I thought was amazing. I thought he had NFL written all over him. But I didn't know what kind of an interesting character he was. Harrington was proof that sometimes a great arm and book smarts do not translate on a football field.
Trent Green (2007): "Scrambled eggs." That's the quote Jason Taylor gave when asked what he thought when he learned Green had been acquired by the Dolphins. Green, you see, had missed a significant portion of 2006 for Kansas City because of a serious concussion. But Cameron wanted him. I remember asking Cameron if he was certain Green could return to his pre-concussion form. "Absolutely," Cameron said. Um, not so much. Green got clocked in a game at Houston and suffered another concussion. That was that.
Cleo Lemon (2005-2007): He came from nowhere in that he wasn't drafted and was actually out of football when he fought his way onto minor league team rosters and eventually the San Diego roster. He was traded to the Dolphins for A.J. Feeley. He had more spunk but not a whole lot more talent.
John Beck (2007-2009): Nice arm. Always seemed afraid and overmatched.
Chad Pennington (2008-present): He was never expected to be the long-term solution. But when he took the Dolphins to the playoffs in 2008, he forever found a place in the heart of fans that needed help forgetting the 1-15 season of 2007. By the end of that season, however, fans had already realized Pennington's arm was not elite. From a leadership standpoint, however, right up there with anyone I've ever covered -- yeah, including Marino.
Chad Henne (2008-present): Maybe he'll be good. Maybe he won't. Will he ever be elite? No idea. That is a troubling place to be after 21 starts. Drew Brees did it. Troy Aikman did it. They had unimpressive starts to their careers and became elite QBs. Many others also had an unimpressive start s to their careers and, well, remained unimpressive. We'll see.
That brings us to Thigpen.
Good luck to him.