« How far from best are the Dolphins in the AFC East? | Main | Mike Dee counters why stadium upgrades make sense »

And Sun Life needs a partial roof why?

In North Texas, an arctic cold front is chilling folks to the bone and has airports in the region on minute-to-minute status with flight delays and runway closings. Schools and businesses in the area are closed. Transit isn't running at 100 percent.

North Texas hosts Super Bowl 45 on Sunday.

In Indianapolis, the feels-like temp is 13-degrees F with a 100 percent chance of precipitation today and tonight and snow expected tomorrow.

Indianapolis hosts Super Bowl 46 next February.

In the metro New York area, it's 35 degrees F with ice pellets dropping from the sky, depending on where you're located. There is also a light, freezing rain in the air and there's a 40 percent chance of snow this weekend.

New York hosts Super Bowl 48 in 2014.

Can someone remind me why the Dolphins and the NFL want to put a partial roof over Sun Life Stadium again?

Last year when the Super Bowl last visited South Florida, NFL commissioner Roger Goodell carried water for the Dolphins, saying he believes Sun Life Stadium needs a partial roof and some significant lighting upgrades so it and South Florida can ensure itself a continued presence in the Super Bowl rotation.

After it rained during the February 2007 Super Bowl at the facility, Goodell fielded complaints from sponsors and other NFL bigwigs upset they got wet on Super Sunday in South Florida. Nevermind that the temps locally were in the 70s.

Well, that worked for a me for a minute.

And then the NFL waived its weather requirements and awarded the game to New York, with its ugly, non-descript, open-air, $1.6 billion stadium in the swamplands of the Meadowlands. And the NFL encouraged Tampa Bay -- in the same state as Miami and with an open air stadium -- to continue bidding for future Super Bowls with no mention of that area needing a roof on its stadium.

And suddenly that rain complaint rang empty.

Then the NFL awarded a Super Bowl to Indianapolis. And the idea that sponsors have to be somewhere warm and fun and sunny got tossed because Indy is none of those this time of year.

Then the NFL awarded a Super Bowl to New Orleans for 2013. And the idea the NFL requires you to have a new stadium to vie for and win a Super Bowl bid got tossed because the Lousiana Superdome opened in 1975, a decade before Joe Robbie Stadium.

So all of the NFL's arguments for Sun Life Stadium and South Florida not being adequate Super Bowl venues are thus ... to put delicately ... crap.

The truth is the NFL was interested in lighting upgrades at Sun Life and those are legit with today's new HD and LED TVs requiring more specialized lighting. But that upgrade would cost perhaps a few million dollars -- nowhere near the quarter-billion or so the Dolphins are seeking to do all of the upgrades for their stadium.

The truth is it is the Dolphins that want the partial roof.Sun-Life-rendering

And the truth is they do no wish to pay for it.

The club has hired lobbyists, gone before local county commissions, and had numerous meetings and ear-tugging sessions with state legislators, just so the upgrades that primarily include the partial roof can be paid for by, well, someone else.

This, by the way, is a significant break from the history of the facility. Joe Robbie built the place on his own dime. Wayne Huizenga signed off on approximately $250 million worth of renovations and upgrades as late as 2008.

Now Stephen Ross, Miami's new owner, wants public funding (tax dollars) going to the next upgrade. Oh, he makes the case the dollars would be siphoned from hotel bed tax sources, meaning tourists would basically pay the freight. He also makes the case those tax dollars cannot be used on, say, police or books or fire fighters or teachers. And, of course, he makes the case that adding a roof to the stadium could, possibly, perhaps, maybe, bring another Super Bowl and the economic boon that comes with it to South Florida in the next decade.

But Ross does not mention in his argument other factoids.

The fact is other local facilities were in line for those bed tax dollars before Sun Life Stadium. Ross doesn't mention that local hotels are in competition with places abroad like Mexico or the Bahamas or Puerto Rico and thus could lose business if word gets out South Florida is a much more expensive place to stay and vacation. (Quickie aside, last year the Dolphins partnered with the Bahamas, encouraging Dolfans to travel there, even while South Florida beaches and hotels could have used more business.)

But I digress.

Ross doesn't mention that South Florida might get a Super Bowl in the next decade anyway. And he doesn't volunteer to cover the difference if the economy that remains in recession mode now gets worse and there's a shortfall of bed tax dollars to cover the cost of his stadium upgrades. Such a shortfall might then be the responsibility of tax funds that do go to police and other services.

All this while Ross is calling for a no-huddle attack during early season home games so the Dolphins can use the hot weather advantage they enjoy early each season -- an advantage the addition of a partial roof might dilute.

Having said all this, I have to think about where I stand on this partial roof idea. I have to consider the meaning of this idea and the manner it is being presented. I have to regard how much trust I have in the politicians and lobbyists that would be behind it. I have to consider where I believe the economy is likely to head and what effect losing one Super Bowl might or might not have on my town. I have to regard that billionair Stephen Ross wants tourists to pay for upgrades to his stadium.

Considering ....

Still considering ....

And then I have to tell you, if Ross wants to drop a partial roof on his staduim, he is more than welcome to do so. It's his stadium, after all.

But buy the argument about it being an NFL requirement for having nice weather at the Super Bowl? No. Buy the idea that it will bring more Super Bowls to town? No. Buy the idea of paying for it with public monies? Oh, hell no! 

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451b26169e20147e231ec07970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference And Sun Life needs a partial roof why?:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

He'll be back, likely never left. That bobbyd is as stubborn as a tick.

Just wish he, her (it) would spin off a positive point of view once in a while...

I bet he's lurking the edges of some dark alley way as I type. The alley way being stuff conjured in the head...

He-he!

S.Ross is concerned about the partial roof, then he should have hired a better HC instead of extending Sparano and Ireland !! Bad decision that is going to haunt this franchise for the next decade.. No fans wants to see another season of not making the playoffs..

The problem with this stupid idea of a roof is these rich a-holes that got wet!!

But it's more stupid that the NFL has commissioner that will put a city that's probably has hold more Superbowls that any other city in that predicament

Rodger Gidell has to be fire this guy is the worst commissioner in the history of the NFL, he is making teams play out of the country risking NFL players lives from possible terrorist attacks especially in Europe, not only that long fight always a risk when flying to that Side of the world, And rumors are,that in the future to host a Superbowl in Europe! I telling you this guy is screwing up the NFL with all these rule changes fines that are ridiculous take the fun out of football and turn it into a political atmosphere! What a joker he is and know I guarantee he is on the owners side and the new CBA with be prolonged because of this idiot!

I know I know what you are going to say, " well you should be the commissioner!! MAYBE I SHOULD HA!

Armando, what a bunch of BS, so we got rained on one year!!!! Big deal! We have the best weather come SB time. Tampa area is lacking compared to Miami and So. Beach, no place in the country compares to us!!!!

I live in Tampa and trust me it has nothing on S. Florida (where i was raised 20 years of my life). Funny thing is how much I knew when I read what Goodell said about the SB in Miami and then turn and give it to NY how much BS the whole of the NFL really is... I love my Dolphins but when Sports starts to adversely affect the people's way of living something is wrong...The best way to strike back at them is when the lock-out happens just stop going to any football games period. With the economy the way it is we could all use the extra money in our pocket. I say if this is truly for the fans, stuff like lock-outs and using our money shouldn't even be an issue. Let them all sink together. LET'S GO LOCK-OUT! LET'S GO! CLAP CLAP.

Stephen Ross is a jackass idiot. What else is new?

That model of the stadium makes it look ugly it's just stupid to hold the city of Mia hostage because it needs a roof!! NFL is getting out of control and the players are the only ones to stop them and control the bull s h I t and fire Rodger Gidell what a BIG A S S HOLE

Mrmikejohnson you right but the NFL commissioner is the biggest A S S H O L E AND HE IS TURING THE NFL AS BIG BULLYS!!!!! And everyone will be saying the something soon very soon!

Right on Ray, could not agree with you more..... Godell is an A.Z.Z.!!!
He needs to step down get out of the way and let someone who knows about football run the league..... he will single handed destroy the NFL!!

Mando you are an idiot and the sheep that regurgitate all your comments and just as brain dead! Good thing you do not run the NFL or run a team.

WAY TO TURN THIS PICE OF CRAP BLOG IN TO YOUR POLITICAL SOAP BOX ASS-MANDO! KEEP ON TRACK AND TALK SPORTS JACK-WAGON!

Hey Mando,
One correction not only is the Meadowlands in the swamp it's a chemical dump!!!

Ross can pay his own bills thank you! Also, Godell is a f-ing idiot. Hope he freezes his ass off on NY!!!!

We could build three domed stadiums with the money our governator, Skeletor stole from Medicare!

i think it is a joke we have to do anything to get a super bowl. we are the best place to have one, without a doubt. I think he said that to help us get financing for new upgrades but doesn't require it at all. I for one would love a roof though. I am 50 now and with my medication and lupus can't sit in the sun more than 30 minutes without severe relapse. With the older population in Florida, there are many diseases as well as older people who just can't tolerate the sun. I would much rather sit in a blizzard than 90 degree scorching. I can always add warmth with layers and a coat. I have had season tickets 35 years but can no longer attend day games. I for one would love a roof one way or another.

« 1 2 3

The comments to this entry are closed.