« Brandon Marshall reports to Dolphins -- early | Main | DeAngelo Williams returns to Carolina :( »

Tyler Thigpen gone, message sent to Chad Henne

[First off, thank you for a record day on the blog yesterday. Incredible how a little actual football news turns this blog into a monster. GRRRRR! Anyway, continue to stay here or return here often throughout the day as the Dolphins continue to operate in stealthy fashion while folks like me chase what's going on from other less-than-perfect, agenda-driven angles. What can I say? You get shut out, you do what you have to do.]

Now to the news and analysis:

Tyler Thigpen is a Buffalo Bill. He has agreed to join that team in return for a three-year contract that gives him a chance to compete for a starting job against Ryan Fitzpatrick. Fitzpatrick will win that competition. The deal sends Thigpen packing after a year and a half in Miami and reunites him with Buffalo coach Chan Gailey, who was Thigpen's offensive coordinator in Kansas City in 2008 when Thigpen enjoyed his best NFL season.

Even though the Dolphins showed casual interest in keeping Thigpen, I do not see this as a big loss, folks.

I know many of you thought Thigpen had potential to chase a starting job. Me? I shared that thinking until he got on the field in 2009 against Pittsburgh and last year against Chicago and was ineffective both times. Thigpen has the gift of adding spark. You see it when he enters a game and the pace picks up.

But Thigpen also is cursed with inconsistency. He'll lead an energy-lifting touchdown drive on one possession. And throw an interception and go three-and-out on the next two possessions.

Thigpen lovers will say that inconsistency in Miami was a result of his little opportunity to work with the first-team offense. Great, so explain his similar inconsistency in Kansas City when he was the starter for 11 games.

So the Dolphins will have a new backup quarterback for 2011.

They're also trying to add a new starting quarterback for 2011.

Hear that, Chad Henne? Hear that Henne supporters?

I have confirmed that Miami is heavily involved in trying to add Kyle Orton while various reports which I've not been able to independently confirm have linked the Dolphins to Matt Hasselbeck. I can see the Orton thing. I don't understand the Hasselbeck fling one bit.

[7:45 AM update: The Hasselbeck fling is not a thing in Miami after all. He is going to the Tennesse Titans. That obviously limits the Dolphins to a focus on Orton with a possible fallback being Marc Bulger or Vince Young.]

Orton is better than Chad Henne, or at least has been the past two years. Is he the man? Is he a franchise quarterback? No. Does he have a superstar arm? Can he escape the rush and turn disaster into dynamics? No.

But he's better than Chad Henne.

And right now, that seems to be good enough for the Dolphins who at last check were hopeful of adding Orton in trade from the Denver Broncos. Problem right now is the Broncos apparently have at least one other team on their line and are trying to reel in the highest draft pick compensation possible.

I do not know the specifics of what the Dolphins have offered (if anything, officially) but I understand the Broncos were asking for a first-round pick initially and are seeded in the second-round asking price of late. Really, Denver? A second for Kyle Orton?

The Dolphins aren't quite ready to do that, apparently. I hope they don't have to at that price. I would more comfortably understand yielding a conditional pick in which Miami gives up a fourth-rounder that could be a third if Orton takes the team to the playoffs, and maybe a second if he advances them to the AFC title game perhaps. (Yes, improbable, but I'm a dreamer.)

Bottom line: Be it either Orton or Hasselbeck, the point is clear the Dolphins are trying to add a veteran quarterback whose resume is superior to Chad Henne's because, well, they are trying to replace Chad Henne even if it's on a short-term basis.

Good for Miami.

Henne is young. He is talented. He has potential. But he has not earned the right to go into training camp unchallenged. He was benched in the 2010 season-finale, if you remember, the second time in the season he suffered that fate. That does not translate to, as some of you have suggested, "sticking with Henne to see if he develops."

The Dolphins are not afforded the luxury of seeing if Henne develops. Both Tony Sparano and Jeff Ireland want to, have to, win now to secure the footing underneath themselves. Banking on Henne to either develop or flop for a third consecutive season is not the most certain way to secure one's footing.

Henne should be watching this and understanding. He must realize he still has a chance to win the job if he, well, wins the job. But he must realize this isn't 2010 when the job was simply handed to him without a competition.

The hope here is this itself makes Henne better. Nothing like a realistic view of the situation to sober the spirit and steel the mind. Would be nice if it improves the decision-making and long-range accuracy, also.

By the way, regardless of whom the Dolphins add -- and it will not be Donovan McNabb as some of you lobbied for -- the idea is not simply to hand over the job. Sure, Orton or Hasselbeck come with reputations. But the Dolphins can still sell the competition idea to the public and Henne.

That can only make everyone better.

Follow me on twitta, as they say in Boston.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451b26169e2014e8a2775a4970d

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Tyler Thigpen gone, message sent to Chad Henne:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

VY will never be a passing wizard like Marino.

His QB running skills are comparable to Doug Williams earlier years with the Bucs. VY could extend his career by copying Williams (by becoming more of a pocket QB).

VY has enough upside to become a very good QB. The Fins should do a lot better this year. Any QB would beat out Henne.

suck for luck!

Please Kyle Orton...give me a break. Its Carson Palmer or just stick with what we have. ORTON no better then Henne...PLEASE

ARMANDO,

I don't get how you mention Henne's 2010 benching as a factor for signing Orton when in fact Kyle was benched the LAST 3 GAMES of 2010.

How do you explain Orton's 2 games prior to his benching when he went a combined 28/69 for 283 yards, 41%, 4.1 YPA, 0 TD, 3 INT, and roughly a 35 QBR??????

I dont think that Henne has been the complete problem over the last 2 seasons, when you have a offence cordinator that doesnt like to take the risks and have ago at the big plays, and only wants to run the ball all the time, the other teams know what is comeing and cover that, also we havent had the weapons other than marshall and bess, they both were double teamed most of the time, we havent had any speed guys to get in behind the defence for the long ball, we may have these things this year, in Gates, also our new cordinator he likes taking a risk, and also we will have someone to compete against Henne for the starting job. I think we might go well this year. Only time will tell. But to say Henne has been the problem and only the problem I think is abit far fetched.

I would give up a 3rd rounders at most for Orton. We need to look a RB, I like Reggie Bush. He can return kicks, 3rd down RB, plus a great receiver out of the back field. Plus he has lots of SPEED. And if that fails I think you have to resign Brown, hes a solid running back, you know what your getting with him.

Damn Armando, I feel bad for you... I hate talking on the phone this long.

First off, anyone who wants Vince Young under center is a masochist. Way too much baggage and on is best day he's a mediocre passer. Super Bowl winning teams have QB's who make plays from the pocket.

Is Orton better than Henne right now? Yep. Would I give up a 2nd or 3rd for him? Nope. Fact is Henne has less than 30 starts under his belt. He's a big, strong guy with a big arm. He's got alot of the tools that good QB's have. He's also shown flashes of brilliance in his 2 years of PT.

Those factors in no way guarantee success, but history shows us with many successful, Pro Bowl level QB's, it "clicks" for them somewhere around the 35 start mark. The game slows down. Henne right now is in that natural growth arc of many QB's. No reason to pull the plug now and essentially waste the last 2 years. Give him this season, see if he makes the "3rd year leap"

BTW, if Henne flops, or simply treads water this year and doesnt improve, there is a really good crop of QB's coming out in next years draft. There will be another group of Orton-like vets that can be stop gaps, and Miami can take a shot on a 1st round QB.

hell...i'll play quarterback. gimme the damn ball!

With Palmer unavailable, Orton is the best choice. It's up to Jeff Ireland to find the right formula (price) so that the team does not suffer in the long run by giving draft picks in exchange.

Forget signing Orton because Henne is actually better so bring in Marc Bulger. Orton is not worth the money nor a long contract.
Henne, Bulger and Devlin/Brandstater

All this player transaction talk is well and good, but if we can't (again) defend the TE down the middle, or ANYWHERE, for that matter, what difference does it make?

But if we HAVE to discuss players, I'd be more interested in beefing up our often injured O-Line, and getting a corner or safety that can actually hang on to an interception.
And get Bradshaw.

seems clear to me that you didn't even see the pittsburgh game. thigpen played really well against pittsburgh. you either have a vague memory, or just looked at the box score.

vEnMdm rvnnyytvfaso, [url=http://lduuwthktteo.com/]lduuwthktteo[/url], [link=http://sjmozmluqsnd.com/]sjmozmluqsnd[/link], http://rjoldxfpsxbw.com/

« 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

The comments to this entry are closed.