« Good Trade? Or Bad? Vote! | Main | Ramirez Not in Lineup; Badenhop on DL »

The Bad With the Good

         By reaching base five times in six trips to the plate on Saturday, Nick Johnson lived up to his billing. His high on-base percentage was precisely the reason the Marlins traded for him, and he impressed in that area right from the get-go. But his debut was not without blemishes. He failed to cover first on a bunt and was thrown out at third for the final out of the fourth inning when trying to stretch a double into a triple. He was also thrown out on an attempted steal of second on what was likely a missed hit-and-run sign by Emilio Bonifacio.

         But Saturday's loss to the Cubs raises more serious concerns for the Marlins. They are:

         1) Their fifth starter. Who exactly is he? Burke Badenhop? Not after Saturday. He gave up six runs and failed to make it out of the second inning. Badenhop has done well in the long relief role, and he endeared himself to teammates when he drilled the Dodgers' Orlando Hudson last weekend. But it's hard to make a case for him as a starter, and he'll likely return to the bullpen. As the Marlins failed to reel in a starter -- too expensive, they said -- at the trading deadline, they're now forced to reach into the minors to find their fifth guy. Look for Sean West to make a return even though the rookie was sent back to Double A Jacksonville because he lacked command of his secondary pitches.

          2) Their third baseman. Jorge Cantu's return to the hot corner did not go well. Displaced by Johnson at third base, Cantu returned to the other side of the diamond and was charged with a pair of throwing errors on Saturday. Both throws were wide left, and the second of the two ended up costing the Marlins two huge runs in the ninth. Manager Fredi Gonzalez said it's going to be a simple matter of time before Cantu gets it together, and Cantu said he'll start lining up his throws with more practice. But Cantu was no Brooks Robinson at third last season, either, so it'll be interesting to see how the position switch works out in the end.

          3) Their closer. I know Leo Nunez wasn't in a save situation when he entered in the 10th on Saturday. But giving up a leadoff home run to Derrek Lee, then hammering Aramis Ramirez near the elbow with a pitch, wasn't exactly a confidence builder if you're a Marlins fan. Matt Lindstrom is back in the bullpen (he remained there Saturday), but he's being eased back and the ninth inning will belong to Nunez for now. The Marlins engaged the Padres in trade discussions for Heath Bell, but the asking price was too high and they backed out.

         I ran a poll after Friday's trade, one in which about 84 percent of nearly 400 respondents thought that the Marlins made the right move by acquiring Johnson. By far, it was a more popular verdict than the Marlins erring in not trading for a starting pitcher (5.2 percent) or a closer (4.9). Now I wonder if, after analyzing Saturday's loss, opinions have changed any.

        The phone lines are open.....



Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.


I was one of the people who were just excited the Marlins made a move. I've always liked Johnson and he did well in his first game reaching base 5 times, however I knew it would be difficult for Cantu. His lingering arm injury and 3B not being his natural position how could you expect him to just go back across the diamond. The other problems include a lack of speed at the top of the line-up.. Coghlan has just above average speed and Johnson with his surgically repaired ankle certainly has trouble getting up the line. The Marlins will miss Bonifacio in the line-up everyday. Most fans seem to get on him because of his low OBP and his # of errors at 3B but realistically he has been playing great defensively at 3rd as of late and he has been scoring runs at an incredible rate when he does get on (which he has doen so more frequently)...The Marlins didn't get a chance to miss him yet because of Hanley getting beamed in the leg, but when his is absent from the line-up and Hanley goes back to being the fastest player in the line-up, he will surely be missed. Also.. sending BC to the minors gives the Marlins limited defensive outfield options. Ross is great defensivly in CF (his catch the other night was amazing). But LF is new to Coghlan and its too bad that can't be an excuse for Hermida in RF..(I really thought if the Marlins were going to add a position player it would have involved trading him away).

Bottom-line: The Marlins couldn't afford (not because of money but because of the talent they would have to give up for most likely a rental player) to acquire a closer like Heath Bell or a 5th starter and they obviously could not buy themselves a player either. They gave up just one average prospect for Nick Johnson and he didn't cost them a cent more then the prorated minimum. They say sometimes the best things in life are free.. however I think the Marlins will continue to pay defensively with this acquisition.


why not move cantu to RF and put blazzing speed back at 3rd. Cantu's has to be better than hermida in RF....


Cantu has never played RF and he if his arm is a problem at 3B it would be worst in that position. Long term solution is the likely return of Cameron Maybin to CF and Ross back to RF. Uggla and Hermida shouldn't be back next year, Cantu could return to 1B if Johnson isn't re-signed and Bonifacio to 2B his natural position. Then a 3B would need to be signed or acquired. Then the defense looks good to me. Until then its going to be iffy.

The comments to this entry are closed.