« Why Florida lost to Georgia and how to prevent it, according to Meyer | Main | NOTEBOOK: Gators split over Presidential candidates »

My All-Florida college football ballot revealed

GAINESVILLE -- As promised, here's a look at my All-Florida ballot as it stands after the eighth week of the college football season. The annual Miami Herald All-Florida College Football Team will be published after the regular season. The Herald's All-Florida Team is voted upon by a collection of college football writers and editors at The Miami Herald.

QB Tim Tebow, Florida junior, PICTURED: USF quarterback Matt Grothe was on my initial ballot but Tebow moves Tebow_2into the top spot among in-state quarterbacks. Tebow has been consistent over the past four weeks while Grothe played erratically in losses to Pittsburgh and Louisville. Grothe threw one interception against Pitt and two against Louisville on Saturday. Meanwhile, Tebow has tossed 12 touchdowns and only two interceptions in seven games. (OK, maybe that's not much of a difference.) Tebow has one loss and led the Gators to a win over LSU, a team ranked in the AP top 5 at the time.
QBs to consider: Matt Grothe, USF junior (14 touchdown passes and 1,896 yards passing, three rushing touchdowns). Curtis Pulley, Florida A&M junior (Exploded in last two games with 424 yards passing and six touchdowns and 219 yards rushing). Christian Ponder, FSU redshirt sophomore (Impressive rushing performance in win against Miami...Completed 11-of-19 attempts and a touchdown on Saturday in win against Va. Tech).

RB Antone Smith, FSU senior: Smith has 11 rushing touchdowns in seven games. He had 540 yards rushing on 109 carries.
RBs to consider: Charles Pierre, FAU senior: Pierre leads in-state FBS running backs with 589 yards on 99 carries and four touchdowns). Rudell Small, Jacksonville sophomore (Leads all in-state running backs with 825 yards on 154 carries. Small has rushed for seven touchdowns.

WR Percy Harvin, UF junior, PICTURED: Despite sitting out the season opener, Harvin is third among in-state FBS Percyharvin_002_2receivers for the most receptions (26). He is tied for the lead among all in-state receivers in touchdown catches (six). He has 429 receiving yards. Harvin's effort in the Gators running game puts him over the top, though. On the ground, Harvin is averaging 6.8 yards per carry (212 yards on 31 carries) and has three rushing touchdowns.
WR Kevin Elliott, Florida A&M freshman: We can't ignore Elliott anymore. He has been solid all season and now leads all in-state receivers with 40 receptions for 535 yards and six touchdowns.
Cortez Gent, FAU junior: 31 receptions for 474 yards and three touchdowns, including a game-winning score last week.

TE Jamari Grant, FAU junior: Grant (6-5, 210 pounds) leads all in-state tight ends with 26 receptions for 380 yards and a touchdown.
TEs to consider: Aaron Hernandez, Florida sophomore (Hernandez began the season as a catch-first tight end but has grown into a respected blocker over the last three games. He has 15 receptions for 145 yards and two touchdowns. Eric Kirchenberg, FIU senior (A dedicated team leader, Kirchenberg is an excellent blocker and has nine receptions for 94 yards and one touchdown.

OT Jason Fox, Miami junior: While the 'Canes offense struggled earlier this season, Fox was a mainstay and continues to be a player the team's players and coaches rely on for leadership.
OT Patrick Brown, UCF junior: Could be the Knights' most highly drafted player in school history in April.
OG Rodney Hudson, FSU sophomore: Continues to prove himself as the best lineman in the state. Had his way with the Miami defensive line.
Pouncey_3OG Mike Pouncey, UF sophomore, PICTURED: This pulling guard has been a key to Florida's option attack, which has launched the stardom of UF running backs Jeff Demps and Chris Rainey.
C Maurice Pouncey, UF sophomore, PICTURED: An important leader and offensive line captain of the Gators' offense.
OLs to consider: Andy Leavine, FIU junior tackle (Leavine is coming into his own). FSU freshman tackle Andrew Datko (This Fort Lauderdale St. Thomas Aquinas alum is making a major impact). UF senior tackle Phil Trautwein, Miami junior tackle Chris Rutledge, Miami sophomore guard Orlando Franklin, FAU senior tackle John Rizzo, Jacksonville sophomore tackle Leonard Payton.

ATH Jeff Demps, UF freshman
: I really wanted to find a way to leave Demps off my ballot because he's a freshman. But, alas, he's just too stinking good. Demps only has 30 carries this season but he leads the Gators in rushing (357 yards). He's averaged 11.9 yards per carry and has scored four rushing touchdowns. Last Saturday he carried a screen pass for a 61-yard score. In addition to his offensive contributions, Demps has blocked two punts, which led to nine UF points.

DL Everette Brown, FSU redshirt junior: Proving to be one of the best defenders in the state. 11 tackles behind the line, six sacks, forced fumble.
Ncf_i_selvie_195DL George Selvie, USF junior, PICTURED: USF's bye week did Selvie good. He was back to his old form against Louisville with seven tackles, including four tackles for losses and two sacks. Selvie has 32 tackles this season with 10 tackles for losses and five sacks.
DL Jermaine Cunningham, UF junior: Cunningham leads UF linemen with 30 tackles, including 4.5 tackles for losses and three sacks.
DL Lawrence Marsh, UF redshirt sophomore: Believe it or not, Marsh is having an All-Florida type of year. He has 19 tackles to go along with 5.5 tackles for losses and three sacks. Florida's defense is only allowing 102.7 yards per game (ranked third in the SEC) and Marsh is big reason for the success.

LB Brandon Spikes, UF junior: The Gators' defensive leader, Spikes has 52 tackles, 1.5 sacks and two interceptions.
LB Frantz Joseph, FAU redshirt senior: Joseph leads all in-state defenders with 96 tackles, including eight tackles for losses.
LB Tyrone McKenzie, USF redshirt senior: Leads USF with 62 tackles, including seven tackles for losses. Also has seven pass break-ups. He also has one interception and one sack.
LBs to consider: FSU senior Derek Nicholson (Leads FSU's resurgent defense with 41 tackles, including nine behind the line. He also has forced a fumble and recovered a fumble.) Miami senior Glenn Cook (50 tackles).

JoehadenCB Joe Haden, UF sophomore, PICTURED: Haden leads all in-state cornerbacks with 40 tackles. He also has a sack, an interception (returned 24 yards), a forced fumble and fumble recovery.
CB Tony Gaitor, FIU sophomore: A break-out season for Gaitor is turning into an All-Florida season. The former Miami Northwestern star has three interceptions (returned for 98 yards) to go along with 33 tackles. He also has seven pass break-ups and a fumble recovery (returned 20 yards).
CBs to consider: Miami junior Chavez Grant (19 tackles, six pass break-ups). FSU redshirt senior Tony Carter (Carter has two interceptions and four pass deflections to go along with 16 tackles.)

Ahmad S Travis Roland, Bethune-Cookman senior
: Roland is having an amazing season and it's not going overlooked. (At least not by Gator Clause.) Roland leads his team in tackles (56), tackles behind the line (10.5), sacks (6.5). He has one interception for a 47-yard return, two forced fumbles, two pass break-ups and he has also recovered two fumbles.
S Ahmad Black, UF sophomore, PICTURED: Once an emergency fill-in at strong safety, Black has risen to greatness quickly. He leads UF with three interceptions with 120 return yards to go along with 29 tackles. He has also forced a fumble and blocked a field goal.

ATH Scott Bryant, FIU junior: This Lakeland native leads FIU with 59 tackles, including 5.5 tackles for losses. He also has a sack, a pass break-up and two forced fumbles. 

ATH Brandon James, UF junior: James leads Florida with 860 all-purpose yards and most of those yards came by way of amazing returns. He has 374 return yards on kickoffs (28.8 yards per) and 363 return yards on punts (20.2 yards per). James has scored five touchdowns, including two on punt returns. James has also recovered a fumble on punt coverage and converted a fake punt for a first down against Arkansas.

K Graham Gano, FSU senior: Gano has made 13-of-14 field goals and 14 PATs for 53 points.

P Chas Henry, UF sophomore: Henry is averaging 43.8 yards per punt while UF's punt coverage unit is only allowing an average five yards per punt return.

Here's the breakdown of my All-Florida ballot by school:
UF 12, FSU 4, FAU 3, FIU 2, USF 2, UCF 1, Miami 1, Bethune-Cookman 1, Florida A&M 1 

1. Florida (6-1, 4-1 in the Southeastern Conference): The Gators are now playing like one of the best teams in college football. Georgia looms.
2. Florida State (6-1, 3-1 in the Atlantic Coast Conference): Don't look now but the 'Noles are sitting atop the ACC standings and their young quarterback is building confidence.
3. Miami (5-3, 2-2 in ACC): The Canes are surging behind their duo of underclassmen quarterbacks. A collection of talented freshmen have Miami on the fast track.
4. USF (6-2, 1-2 in the Big East Conference): The Bulls fall behind the 'Noles and 'Canes in the All-Florida power rankings after a loss to Louisville.
5. FIU (3-4, 2-1 in the Sun Belt Conference): The Golden Panthers travel to La.-Lafayette for a huge conference game this Saturday.
6. FAU (3-5, 1-2 in Sun Belt): Dramatic win for FAU on Saturday night against La.-Monroe.
7. UCF (2-4, 1-1 in Conference USA): Central Florida enjoyed a bye week. Hope the Knights are ready for undefeated Tulsa.
8. Florida A&M (6-2, 2-2 in Mid-Eastern Athletic Conference) Have the Rattlers found a star in freshman receiver Kevin Elliott? Yes.
9. Bethune-Cookman (5-2, 2-2 in MEAC)
10. Jacksonville (5-3, 3-1 in Pioneer Conference)

Discussion topics:
--You, the loyal reader, can lobby for one player that's not on my ballot. Let me read your take and I'll consider it.
--Are 12 Florida Gators too many for my ballot. I realize I cover the Gators and might be slightly swayed towards nominating players I see every day, but as of right now I think the state's balance of power is about this proportional.
--Is there another defensive lineman out there better than Lawrence Marsh? I didn't want to put him on the team but I analyzed each team's best defensive linemen but still kept coming back to Marsh. Did I overlook somebody or is Marsh the guy?
--Is Miami only worthy of one All-Florida spot? They've got some good young players but every time I stacked them against the competition the 'Canes fell short.
--FAU with three picks? It seems a little off but those three players are excellent and could star for any team in the state, in my opinion. Perhaps Miami tight end Dedrick Epps?
--Welcome to the conversation, FIU. Last season, I didn't nominate a single Golden Panther. Bryant (a close friend of Ahmad Black's, by the way) and Gaitor are serious playmakers on FIU's defense.
--Should I give Florida A&M and Bethune-Cookman this much love on my ballot?
--Should Ahmad Black be on my ballot? What about FSU's Myron Rolle or USF's Nate Allen or UF's Major Wright, for that matter? Wright has two interceptions this season and 35 tackles.
--Should Grothe be on my ballot instead of Tebow?



TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference My All-Florida college football ballot revealed:


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

OT JASON FOX???? C'mon man don't throw those guys a bone. Let em earn honors.

Glad to see you come around and put cunningham over dunlap like i suggested after your first edition.

Like it, jo. Not only should Black be on there, but Wright should be as well. I think 13 total gators (including Wright) would've been perfect. There is no denying how this secondary has dominated the competition.

jo im a big gator fan but i think you should have AT LEAST considered sean spence from UM ... that man is a monster and is the future of UM linebackers


Like everyone else, I love Sean's game and I certainly consider him. He has 39 tackles, including 4.5 tackles for losses. He wasn't a starter at the beginning of the season, so that hurts him right now. That said, if he continues to improve this season he could make the list.

Adam S.,

UF's secondary has been dominate ... but now they get to actually face a great (and experienced) quarterback. We'll see how they respond.


I don't disagree. But you were putting players in there for their performances up until this point and Major Wright is a BIG part of their current dominance.

So, is it Black or Wright?


That has to be the most pathetic college football game crowd I have ever seen. U R a JOKE !



We didn't quit last year??? That is news to me, after seeing Virginia game. And pb, I would bet you a million dollars that the Canes will never win the ACC with a QB who can't average 7 yards per pass attempt, never the less the 4.9 Marve averages... Get real if you think throwing for less than 200 yards a game is going to win anything in the 2008 college football era


alas, not a soul cares. The foamy mouth canesfool should chime in.


You don’t have any “fellas” stool. Everyone hates U like poison.

King Randy speaking about upcoming UF/GA game-

“You better go to that game. You would get a great story. Don’t come to ours. I’m serious.

What on earth is this fool thinking? Not a week goes by that this goober doesn't make some serious blunder. Give him a 5 year extension immediately.

"UVA's defense is not that good against the run so I expect JJ and GC to run all over them." -canesrule 9'ships

Those guys define MEDIOCRE. Why does cane fan continue to carry on about "Coop and Baby J?" Those guys are frauds.

Our offensive line...blah blah blah...need some reps...blah blah blah....injuries....blah blah blah..


If the U is going to wear black uni's, they should wear them against Virginia to commemorate the massacre in the Orange Bowl

48-0 will never go away.....ever

Neither will our losing the SEC 'ship for 53 years staight! We Suck!
0-53 in the SEC

Actually VIRGINIA will be wearing black to commemorate the victims of the Orange Bowl massacre.

That's the steaming hot dag that Art power dumped on the U field for firing him. A curse that will never go away unless he is rehired.

"If the U is going to wear black uni's, they should wear them against Virginia to commemorate the massacre in the Orange Bowl."


That one made me laugh out loud. That's high-quality smack.


LOL yes, that was funny Coke.

jo, both Black and Wright.

Thank you cane fans for posting embarrassing U smack over here. It's very entertaining.

Your original Grothe over Tebow pick was stupid. This is all irrelevant. Florida-Georgia is all that matters this week. After this game your "all Florida team will be the Florida Gators.

Nice, MV. Didn't know jo put Grothe there before the season. If that's the case, with all due respect, yeah, that was pretty stupid.

My first ballot came out during the third or fourth week. At that time, Grothe had just led a comeback against Kansas and Tebow was struggling. I stand by my initial ballot. As for the relevancy of the All-Florida team...the relevancy of anything is debatable.

It's about Florida football and this is my blog. Therefore, I find it relevant. Also, it took me a long time to compile the stats and information for the readers of this blog.



I actually love your blog and appreciate the content. I wouldn't comment if I didn't like it. I'm so high on the gators right now I personally don't care about any other players from other florida schools, but I like reading about it. Keep up the good work!


Grothe is the poor-man's Tim Tebow!


I agree with MV. As I said, "with all due respect." You do a great job here, I just wish there was less TRASH on the comments so we could have more intelligent discussions.

P.S. - Who questioned the relevancy? I certainly did not.



First of all let me congratulate you on your All Florida selections. There is one athlete that deserves a look, he is Leroy Vann the kick off and Punt return specialist at FAMU. Below are his MEAC stats through 8 games in addition to the 2 kick off returns he has returned 2 punts for touchdowns as well. I agree his AP yards are not as good as James but I think he deserves a mention.

VANN,L-Flor 8 28 712 2 99 25.4

ALL PURPOSE G Rush Rcv PR KR Yards Yards/G
VANN,L-Flor 8 0 0 249 712 961 120.1

Of course you should show love to FAMU and BCU.


Interesting. No offense to him or those teams, but those are numbers against significantly weaker competition than is even faced in the ACC and Big East. Sorry, the numbers are great, but not deserving of being the best in FL.

At least we NEVER lost a NC 62-24. I would rather lose 48-0 with a mediCoker team than lose in a NC that bad, losers!!!
We even won our first National Title before U even won your conference.
Just accept it. Why are U fighting it? It just makes no sense.
#1 recruiting class in 2008, and 2009's climbing the charts. Where is UF at? ESPN doesn't even have UF in the top 15.
UF is done, over, bye bye, NEXT!, in our shadow, only wins NCs when THE U is down.
Just stick to Bball, oops, never mind...NIT's finest!
Posted by: U wish U were THE U, but Ur not so get a clUe!!! |

BLUE, U lost to THE U 41-16 in the Swamp. Why are U still blogging? UFreakin suck!!!
September 7 at No. 20 Florida W 41-16
September 6 No. 17 Florida W 38-33 (QUITTERS, and we beat U with Ur own. Remember the Gator chomp throat slash? Ha Ha!)
December 31 vs. No. 25 Florida W 27-10 (feeling just PEACHY I must say! Ha Ha!)
Miami 28 wins to UF's 25. Hmmmm....
Posted by: U wish U were THE U, but Ur not so get a clUe!!

BLUE, we haven't quit all season. New team calls for new times, num num.
Did U quit on OLE MISS? Oh, no, they just punched U in the mouth.
Maybe cry baby Teblow can win this weekend since he promised Gaytor nation between every sniff sniff. Good luck with that one.
Posted by: U wish U were THE U, but Ur not so get a clUe!!! |

5 Times, why do you hide the fact that your NC in 1983 was won after the Gators gave Miami a good country size beating at the Swamp 28-3?

You failed to recognize the Gators victory this year, the record is 26-28 Miami.

Looking at next year’s recruiting class the Canes have 17 with 5 top 150 and the Gators have 12 with 7 top 150 (which includes Dee Finley). If you do the math, Florida has more talent in the top 150 than Miami, but not enough of recruits to be in the top 15. Let’s wait until signing day before deciding which team did better.

You go back to the good old days, but a baby who was born in 1908 is probably dead by now and as of today your team is dead in the water. The scUms do not have one lousy point in the National Rankings!

The scUms are unimportant; nobody talks about your dumb team except couch-potato fans like you.

Tebow's promise has inspired and catapulted the Gators into the National Championship picture and as for the scUms, the NC is just a dream.

Heck, half the U equals L for LOOSERS.

Get a life, read your UM blogs where all you UM fans, who choose not show up to support your team during its games at Dolphin Stadium, continue to blame O. C. Patric Nix for your lousy offense instead of blaming the guy who hired him, your dreadful head coach "Cry Baby" Shannon who likes to throw his own players under the bus when things do not go well for the scUms.

By the way, is 5 TIMES for five times neurologists had looked inside your scull to find brain matter with no success?

You tell em 1972....The only thing UM does these days is motivate people to push harder when sitting on the can:)

The comments to this entry are closed.