« Gallery | 2014 Leaders, Legends & Lovelies Ball presented by Hispanic LGBT group Unity Coalition | Main | Star guitarist Lee Ritenour to pay tribute to Antonio Carlos Jobim with Jazz Roots finale at Arsht Center »

Federal judges hearing Utah gay marriage case appear divided


DENVER -- A three-judge panel appeared sharply divided as they questioned attorneys Thursday at a hearing over whether to uphold a lower court's ruling that struck down Utah's ban on gay marriage.

One of the judges, Carlos F. Lucero, compared the state's argument that the ban should to the U.S. Supreme Court's infamous Dred Scott decision that denied citizenship and constitutional protections to blacks before the Civil War.

"To argue that public policy can trump a declared constitutional right would be a remarkable proposition," Lucero said.

But Judge Paul J. Kelly Jr. suggested Utah does have the right to reaffirm what has been a centuries-long tradition of heterosexual marriage.

"You are just taking the position they are wrong on this. .... We'll just ignore what the people have decided and the Legislature has done," Kelly said. The swing vote in the case appears to be justice Jerome A. Holmes, who sharply challenged attorneys for both sides.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

The comments to this entry are closed.