« Idols Live Tour Dates | Main | Danny Gokey brings country to Midtown Miami »

Idol elimination: The Twain crashes for ... Siobhan.

Lady a
Shania Twain
night on American Idol Tuesday means a night of pop-country guests on results show at 9 tonight. Lady Antebellum (pictured, AP), currently the hottest music group in any genre, performs, as does Rascal Flatts, the group Lady A supplanted at the top.

Miketwain And then... eliminations. My guess is Mike Lynch is most vulnerable (even if he has never been the worst). Follow live blogging and Twitter commentary.

Perhaps even producers realize less and less people care to see these so-called Idols because instead of the usual group number to open results show, we get a performance from Rascal Flatts who sang their unremarkable new single, Unstoppable. Really wish they would stop.

The bottom three: Mike, Siobhan and ... Casey? This was Casey's best week. The fix is in so long as Lee remains in this competition. In addition to Lee, Aaron and Crystal are safe.

Next week Harry Connick mentors the Top 5 in the Songs of Sinatra. They are going to have the likes of Lee and Crystal, Aaron and whoever survives among the bottom three tackle the master vocalist? Not one of these people are fit to utter the name "Sinatra," let alone sing his music.

Lady Antebellum performed Need You Now. Still waiting for someone to write and perform a better pop song this year. A surebet Song and Record of the Year Grammy nominee, that one. Watch.

Casey bottom two?? That's a surprise given he was TOP 2 last night with Aaron. It'll be Casey or Siobhan going home. Mike's safe.

Finally, viewers cried, "So, you're Siobhan Magnus? That don't impress me much" and the Irish lass screams her last scream on the Idol stage. A passable outcome.

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Lesley

Lee should have been in the bottom three in place of Casey. But I think Siobhan is going home!

HoCo

I think Mike is but I'd be fine with Siobhan and her scream going home. Show has no credility so long as Lee remains.

MrsEvans

How was Lee not in the bottom 3? Oy vey,I need to stop watching this charade!

Lesley

what was that band sons of sylvia? is carrie underwood their benefactor or just their following act? are they country? Indie? What? couldnt make it out or decide if I liked them or not.

MrsEvans

Dunno, I changed the channel. :)

Lesley

I like Rascal Flatts and Lady Antebellum. Question: why do they call it Lady when there's a dude in the band?

Lesley

make that two dudes in the band.

Lesley

now if this isn't the oddest couple since jacko and lisa marie.....shakira and rascal flatts?

MrsEvans

Sinatra week...very relevant...they really need to end this show. It's pathetic. Much like this Shakira performance.

Lesley

If Casey goes, well, that will be good for him...hopefully he has a nice deal waiting for him! But still...

MrsEvans

oh dear...i don't like where this is going. The last idol I truly liked went home in sixth place...way before his time...

MrsEvans

I guess it doesn't matter if he goes now or in a few weeks. We know Lee is going to win so he will have to go at some point. ALthough it would be "wicked cool" to see Siobhan go first.

MrsEvans

Woooohoooooo!!!!

Lesley

siobhan looks pissed and none of the other contestants look too upset that she's going...

MrsEvans

Good job America! Even though I don't believe for a second that votes really matter...

MrsEvans

Maybe Ringling Bros can hire her...she already has the wardrobe!

IdolMom

Siobhan had been dreadful for some time. Managed to make every song sound either lounge-singer or Broadway. A real shame because she had a cute quirky look, but zero edge to her voice. Thank goodness she's going.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment