I'm sounding off, but want to know what people think. What happened to you on the Festival? Good? Bad? Did you play? Did you go? Would you go back?
Checked back into the Miami Music Fest on Saturday night, guilt and a sliver of hope overcoming my annoyance and discouragement from Thursday night. Glad I did. Some things were better - the bands (that I caught), and certainly the turnout were much improved from Thursday night. But judging from what I saw and what I've heard talking to people and in comments and emails, the underlying problems of disorganization, lack of focus and quality remain. And I still think the festival won't succeed unless it seriously addresses them. Moreover, they'll now have to battle skepticism from much of the local music community turned off by this year's experience.
Awesome New Republic playing the Transit Lounge for the Miami Music Festival Friday night. Photo by Alexia Fodere.
On the up side, there were a LOT more people than on Thursday - Tobacco Road and Transit both had good-sized crowds. The tents were better, though still too spacious for the turnout - better to pack 50 people into a small room and pump up their energy and the perception that this show is happening than have them looking around a mostly empty space and wondering if it's more happening somewhere else.
The bands I caught were better too, though most of the acts I saw were selected by people or organizations that picked their own acts for their own showcases, rather than from whoever applied to the Festival site. (Actually, many of the acts I talked to were invited in one way or another, often last minute, leading me to think the Festival organizers either didn't have enough bands applying/accepting or felt they needed some better artists to beef up their random line-up. And a number of artists said they were invited but turned the Festival down.).
Vanne Dazza of Radioboxer performing at Transit Lounge during the Miami Music Festival Friday night. Photo by Alexia Fodere.
At Tobacco Road, Miami Latin-metal-dance-pop (categorize that!) group Music is a Weapon played the hard rock station WHDR's showcase outside, and judging from all the black t-shirts and demi-goth gear, looked like a mostly genre-loyal audience (with a few puzzled middle-aged couples I'm guessing were drawn by the opportunity to, ooh, hear some rock and roll after their nice dinner out). Liked Weaponeers energy and the combination of mohawks and conga and timbal players, but the music wasn't always catchy or coherent enough to be engaging. Upstairs at the Road the room was packed (partly with Music is a Weapon refugees) for the Disc Makers' showcase and Saints on Fire, a punk/hard rock combo with fine musicians and intensity but not a whole lot of originality - but head-banging, hair-tossing rock will never die.
The Patio at Transit, empty of bands and audience when I checked in Thursday night, was full for the SESAC showcase - at least some of them brought out by the performance rights company's connections to the artists and managers who work with them (Miami rock singer-songwriter Alan Hughes said he walked into the SESAC show and got invited to perform by the sound guy - how's that for careful band selection?). Caught a really good Puerto Rican rock group, Habitat (I remember legendary Bowie guitarist Carlos Alomar, a Borinquen, going on about the island's rock scene and how he was going to boost it a decade or so ago and thinking "Puerto Rico and rock? C'mon" but they've got a terrific scene going. Question - how come an island that small can support healthy salsa, and reggaeton, and rock scenes?). Thania Sanz, a country-flavored (not according to her bio, but sounded that way to me) Latin pop rock singer-songwriter, was also good.
Inside hot Brooklyn indie band The Aviation Orange, invited by Festival co-producer Irwin Kornfeld, sounded fantastic - eerie alt power-pop. Their manager said they were a lot happier to be there than most of the local artists I encountered, in part because it was a kind of vacation for them - the Festival had flown the band down from NYC. "Who wouldn't want to come to Miami in December?" he asked. (Habitat was also invited and flown in by SESAC). Aviation Orange has played SXSW, they pull in good audiences (600-1200) in NYC, so their manager was happy to lend our humble little burg some cred. "We're the best band here, we came to give the festival a little legitimacy." And I'm sure all Miami musicians are very grateful. Even so, he said the same thing many here are saying, that the Festival needs to have fewer venues, and fewer, better selected bands, better focus. And then it could be great.
At the miami.com tent which had all the sound problems on Thursday, Mawon, a terrific Haitian-Caribbean band that can swing from rara to compas to reggae, managed to sound pretty good - pulling in people even at 1:30am.
So some things were better. But it won't be enough to save the Festival for another year unless they address the issues that created all the problems: disorganization, bad sound and technical back-up (for any musician, sounding good is what it's all about), focus. And fairness. A lot of local artists opted out because the whole festival set-up seemed like such a mess, or they felt they were being taken advantage of. A lot of significant folks (club owners, promotors, taste-makers etc) felt like they were ignored and disincluded. Some of those who did play had such a bad experience that it will be hard to convince them to come back. And a lot of Miami musicians seemed to feel like the Festival was taking advantage of them - charging them an application fee, getting sponsors, charging for the conference, etc - to make money. I don't know that that's true, but the perception is there.
But a lot of people on the local music scene want a festival. I kept hearing "this is a really good idea, but..." or "this could be/could have been great, but....." I'm guessing some bands are still thrilled they got a chance to play, and some audience folks still had a good time. So there's still an opening. It will be harder to stage the MMF again with the skepticism generated this year, but my guess is that most folks could get past the problems of a first year if things change significantly. Whether they will, or whether there'll be another festival, remains to be seen.
What do you think?