« Prison bill dies 21-19 | Main | Harassment suit falters against Alcee Hastings »

House panel kills controversial charter school proposal

A House panel on Tuesday killed a proposal that would require traditional public schools to share their facilities funds with charter schools.

The 7-7 vote came as a surprise to many in the room, given that the House has traditionally supported charter schools. Three Republicans on the House PreK-12 Education Appropriations Subcommittee, however, found enough fault with the proposed amendment to vote against it. 

Subcommittee Chairwoman Marti Coley, R-Marianna, was among the dissenting votes. "I still have unanswered questions," Coley said after the meeting.

Rep. Michael Bileca, R-Miami, and Rep. Bill Hager, R-Boca Raton, also voted against the amendment. Hager said lawmakers should discuss the overall problems with school facilities funding before creating new rules for charter schools.

(As expected, the Democrats voted no, too.)

The bill, HB 903, ultimately won approval from the subcommittee. As it stands, the bill would prohibit school districts from renewing their contracts with certain low-performing charter schools. It would also require charter schools to post information about their board members and management companies prominently on their websites.

The question of facilities funding for charter schools has been controversial in the House.

When HB 903 was initially filed, it required school districts to share with charter schools based on student enrollment. That language was removed before the bill made its first committee stop -- and added back (albeit in a slightly modified way) on Tuesday.

HB 903 now heads to the House Education Committee.

Its companion in the Senate, sponsored by Sen. Stephen Wise, includes the sharing provision. That bill has met little resistance.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Charles Garner

I would like to commend everyone who voted against HB903 , as a concern parent with kids in public schools I am sad to see the demise of public education .Charter schools being sold to so many uninformed people as the better choice. It is obvious that the funds for public education, The department of correction and all government jobs are easy pickings with the spoils going to the well connected. I believe this country is on a fast slippery slope to HELL with no brakes, because the love of money has replaced the fear of God in the hearts of men. What does it profit a man to gain the whole world and lose his soul.

Linda Kobert

A correction. Senator Wise's companion bill SB1852 was met with huge resistance by a broad alliance of parent groups across FL. 80 speakers were signed up to speak against the bill in committee. Sen. Wise shut them down by limiting discussion to one hour. That time was spent on one single ammendment. The majority were never allowed to speak against the bill itself, and it passed with one lone dissenter. There is large opposition to the effort to give public tax dollars to for profit charter management companies.

Kat McGrory

Good point, Linda. I meant to say the bill has met little resistance from lawmakers. There has indeed been strong opposition from parent groups, school districts and others. Thanks for pointing that out.

The comments to this entry are closed.