« Former Sen. Mandy Dawson pleads guilty in tax evasion case | Main | Rick Scott to Facebook fans: Describe this legislative session »

Team Obama: RomneyCare's contraception rules look like ObamaCare's. Team Romney: False

RomneyceptionMitt Romney and the rest of the Republican establishment are hammering President Obama for the healthcare law that requires insureres to provide coverage of contraceptions. It's a war on religion, they say, because Catholic providers don't believe in subsidizing Onanism (beware, Genesis has some dirty parts).

Now Obama's re-election campaign is hitting back. It has posted a blog entry that says Romney is being hypocritical:

"But the facts tell a different story. Just as he criticizes federal health reform based on the law he passed in Massachusetts, Mitt Romney is attacking the President for providing women with the same access to contraception and preventive health care services Romney did as governor. Our new infographic takes a look at how contraception coverage compares under the Affordable Care Act and the Massachusetts law Romney stood behind."

UPDATE: The Romney campaign finally responded, saying the attack is false: “Governor Romney stands with the Catholic Bishops and all religious organizations in their strenuous objection to this liberty- and conscience-stifling regulation. He is committed to repealing Obamacare entirely. On his first day in office, Mitt Romney will eliminate the Obama administration rule that compels religious institutions to violate the tenets of their own faith. We expect these attacks from President Obama and his liberal friends. But from Newt Gingrich and Rick Santorum, it’s a clear indication of desperation from their campaigns.” – Andrea Saul, Romney spokesperson....

The DNC Attack Is False. Gov. Romney Proposed Eliminating All Coverage Mandates, Including Contraception Requirement.  

 ·         First, they are wrong. Before Mitt Romney became governor, Massachusetts passed a law in 2002 requiring insurance companies to provide contraception coverage.

 ·         In 2005, as Governor, Mitt Romney proposed eliminating ALL coverage mandates as part of health care reform, including the general contraception requirement, that was law before he was governor.

 Newt Gingrich And Rick Santorum Are Wrong. Governor Romney Vetoed An Emergency Contraception Bill.

 ·         That is simply wrong. Newt Gingrich and Rick Santorum are once again peddling misinformation. In 2005, Mitt Romney vetoed an Emergency Contraception bill that would have made the Plan B pill available to young girls without prescription and with no age restriction. The legislature overrode Gov. Romney's veto.

 ·         The law that passed, despite Mitt Romney’s veto, required Catholic hospitals to provide emergency contraception to rape victims

 ·         Newt Gingrich and Rick Santorum are lashing out at their opponents, intentionally spreading misinformation, in an attempt to prop up their campaigns. It’s very sad – and it’s not going to work.


 ·         In 2008, Mitt And Ann Romney Received The Becket Fund’s Canterbury Medal Which “Recognizes Courage In The Defense Of Religious Liberty.” “The Canterbury Medal is the Becket Fund’s highest honor. It recognizes courage in the defense of religious liberty and is named for Canterbury Cathedral, where Thomas à Becket was martyred by the knights of King Henry II for his own defense of religious freedom. The Canterbury Medal is thus given annually to one “who has resolutely and publicly refused to render to Caesar that which is God’s. …Over the years we’ve awarded the Canterbury Medal to many accomplished allies in the fight to keep religion alive in the public square. Here is a list of Canterbury Medalists since the honor was first given in 1997. …2008    Governor & Mrs. Mitt Romney.” (The Becket Fund, Accessed 2/7/12)

 ·         Governor Romney Sided With The Adoption Community Working To Ensure That Catholic Charities Could Continue Their Adoption Services. In 2006, Governor Romney Proposed Legislation That Would Have Allowed Catholic Charities To Continue Their Adoption Services.  "Calling it an issue of 'religious liberty,' Governor Mitt Romney today said he plans to file legislation to permit religious institutions to perform adoptions without violating the tenets of their faith.  Today, the board of Catholic Charities voted to stop doing adoptions because of state law which requires that gays be given equal consideration for the placement of children. Because of the Church’s teaching, Catholic agencies may not provide adoptions to gay parents.  'This is a sad day for neglected and abandoned children. In this case, it’s a mistake for our laws to put the rights of adults over the needs of children. While I respect the board’s decision to stay true to their principles, I find the current state of the law deeply disturbing and a threat to religious freedom,' said Romney."  (Office Of Governor Mitt Romney, "Defending Religious Liberty, Romney To File Bill Exempting Religious Institutions From Gay Adoption Requirement," Press Release, 3/10/06)

o   Governor Romney's Legislation Would Have Allowed Religious Organizations To Provide Adoption Services Consistent With Their Beliefs.  "Romney’s bill would authorize religious organizations to provide adoption services consistent with their beliefs by creating an exemption from the state’s nondiscrimination laws." (Office Of Governor Mitt Romney, "Defending Religious Liberty, Romney To File Bill Exempting Religious Institutions From Gay Adoption Requirement," Press Release, 3/10/06).

 The liberal DailyKos, meanwhile, has linked to a poll suggesting that rank-and-file Catholics aren't really bothered by The Pill Rule.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.


Where has Romney been critical of providing contraceptive services?

Or is it a narrow talking point from Team O that is being distorted?


Better yet, will those calling for contraceptive services to not be included also advocate that hysterectomies also not be covered?


Sam Osborne

One might have thought that former Gov. of Massachusetts Mitt Romney would by now have learned what Newt keeps getting reminded of: that the God of Christianity does not reliably ordain winners and losers and that not all of His followers are of like mind. To wit, the most conspicuous Christian pro football player, Tim Tebow, didn’t appear to have the Holy Ghost whispering the right plays in his ear when they played the Patriots. And then, victorious QB Brady got let down and the Patriots lost to the boys from . . . oh my . . . Gotham City.

But you know, if Mitt were to put on tights, a cape, a mask with ears, and assume Tebow’s gargoyle crouch---Holy Batman! Thus empowered and with two Robins at his side, the robin’ Koch brothers, Mitt wouldn’t need any inconsistent godly favoritism.

It could give Caped Crusader Mitt the edge that some of the earlier followers of his faith could have used when they were being persecuted because of their beliefs by folks who considered themselves real Christians and Americans. Maybe they would not have suffered the Mormon War of 1838, the murder of their founding prophet, Joseph Smith whose 5 assailants were acquitted by a sympathetic jury, and continued assault during their long flight west. With Mitt now standing up for us Catholics (like Newt, Santorum and me) it does make me wonder where the ancestral members of my faith were when his Mormon people were being put on a run for their lives.

frank burnsf

The Church leaders are lying through their teeth -- but what else do church leaders do? They want to limit health insurance in ways that conform to their beliefs, even though their worker's beliefs could be different. Catholic workers don't need to use that insurance for contraception if they don't want to. The bishops, with their delicate consciences are in the same boat as if they paid cash to their workers, and the workers used that cash to buy contraception. In other words, if they can give cash, and the worker decides, they can give unlimited insurance, and the worker decides. This is all about the bishops (a bunch of celibate old men -- "celibate" if you don't count involvements with altar boys) trying to force other people's health decisions, and then blowing the thing way out of proportion. Shame on them.

William Wilson

The Affordable Care Act, President Obama's health-care overhaul passed by Congress last year, was designed to make it easier for Americans in situations like Verone's to get health insurance BTW check "Penny Medical" for more information

The comments to this entry are closed.