« Florida Bar launches voter education campaign on merit retention | Main | Connie Mack Super Pac ad bashes Bill Nelson over Keystone, features Mack's dad »

Sen. Chris Smith releases recommendations for Stand Your Ground reform

Sen. Chris Smith, D-Fort Lauderdale, has released a list of recommendations for amending Florida’s Stand Your Ground law, after a task force he convened debated the language of the law earlier this month.

Among the unanimous recommendations:

- Cases should be presented to a Grand Jury to allow for a cross section of society to determine what a reasonable person would do in that case.
- Educate the public and law enforcement
- Create a system to track self-defense claims in Florida
- Add language requiring an “imminent” danger provision throughout the statute
- Change the “Defense of Others” wording in the law’s title to “Defense of Property”
- Allow law enforcement to detain someone who uses the Stand Your Ground defense while they investigate. 

For more details, visit FloridaStandYourGround.org for the full report.

Smith said he would give his recommendations to Gov. Rick Scott and his public safety task force, which will have its first meeting Tuesday. 

Smith said Lt. Gov. Jennifer Carroll, who chairs the public safety task force, rejected his request to speak at the inaugural meeting and present the recommendations.

“I guess I’ll attend and maybe put it on their windshield wipers in their cars campaign style afterwards,” he said.

Smith, one of only 20 lawmakers who voted against the law in 2005, said his task force agreed unanimously on several ways to clarify the law to make it more effective.

The 18-member group of “legal minds” also had several consensus recommendations, in which at least 12 members agreed on an issue, but there were dissenting opinions.

“Stand your ground has been used way before Trayvon Martin, and it will be used way after Trayvon Martin,” Smith said. “In order to make sure that we have a just legal and safe society, I still believe that the Legislature should act soon and make sure we clarify how we should live in a civilized society in Florida.”

Smith is pushing for a special session for the Legislature to address the law.

“It’s a public safety issue,” he said. 



Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.


Sounds like they're more interested in protecting "property" than "people"! Surely, we have more of a right to kill someone who aims to hurt other people, more than to kill someone who just threatens property.


Leave SYG alone!


I understand why the Lt. Gov. rejected his request to speak at the inaugural meeting and present the recommendations they are totally nonsense.

Kim Hoda

Law enforcement in Florida is a disgrace. They look to arrest people for things that would be considered laughable by police in other states. Florida is known nationwide as the state that handcuffs 7 year olds for fighting on the playground. You want to give Florida police power to detain those who exercise self-defense? All cases should go to the prosecutor for a decision. The average police officer get what 4 months in the academy? A prosecutor is an attorney who have years of education on the subject of law. Give the police NO decision making whatsoever. The police should write reports for referrals only IMHO!

The comments to this entry are closed.