« Judge denies request to stop voter purge | Main | Atwater hopes to reform flawed contracting process by exposing it to sunlight »

Judges continue to grapple with prison privatization

A last-minute change to the state budget last year that would have privatized 29 South Florida prisons continued its march through the courts Wednesday, with judges grappling with how to proceed as the end of the fiscal year looms.

The three-judge panel in the 1st District Court of Appeal may help resolve a year-long dispute over whether top legislators can slip in sweeping budget changes without vetting them through the committee process, and if so, what the limitations are.

“This is a gross misuse of proviso power,” argued M. Stephen Turner, attorney for the Florida Police Benevolent Association, which challenged the privatization plan, winning in lower courts.

Leon County Circuit Judge Jackie Fulford blocked the state last year from shifting 4,000 public correctional officers to private companies, and the upcoming end to the budget year on June 30 means it’s too late to enact the effort. 

Fulford said the Legislature should have passed a stand-alone law rather than use fine print to achieve its aims.

Going forward, judges Nikki Ann Clark, Ronald Swanson and Chief Judge Robert Benton seemed hesitant to issue a decision on a what they called a “moot case.”

But attorneys argued that the ruling could shape future behavior of top lawmakers who determine the budget, allowing  them free reign or warning them against going too far.

In this case, the Legislature’s action was particularly “heinous,” Turner argued, because Gov. Rick Scott couldn’t impose a veto, even if he’d wanted to.

“How in the world could the governor exercise his veto power?,” Turner said. “He would have had to veto the entire (Department of Corrections) budget.”

Scott has publicly supported moving prisons to private companies, including this session’s failed effort to pass 27 prisons and work camps in 18 counties to private hands.

Assistant Attorney General Jonathan Glogau asked the judges to overturn Fulford's ruling and uphold the Legislature’s ability to determine its own proviso language.

Judges may not issue a ruling at all if they decide Attorney General Pam Bondi didn’t have the right to appeal the case after the Department of Corrections declined to do so. The attorney general's office could have asked the circuit court for permission to appeal, but did not.

“The attorney general has the broad power to appear for this case if there’s a public interest,” Glogau argued.

Turner replied, “In this case, the attorney general is not protecting the public, she’s protecting the Legislature.”

Twitter: Britt_alana


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.


The more the courts impinge on the legislature's prerogatives, the less funding the courts will get.

But this is really a case of the government system in Tallahassee trying to protect the government system.

That's why this appellate court has sat on this case, without sitting for a hearing, for so long.

They have been sitting in their new, big ol' Taj Mahal palace ... lazing about in the lap of luxury ... courtesy of the taxpayers ...

Instead of getting their privileged butts in gear and deciding cases in a timely fashion.

 Judge Charles Edelstein (ret.)

Some aspects of privitization have been successful. A visit to the grand canyon national park is a good example. I have been in the criminal justice system for 49 years as a prosecutor, teacher, judge, defense lawyer, consultant and more. I have participated in over 15 jail overcrowding studies around the nation. All of this tells me that privatatizion of criminal justice programs has been a very mixed bag. Jails and prisons need to be held accountable for their operations since our legal system allows them wide latitude in running these facilities. Inmates and correctional officers (for the latter, with an exception being CA) have little access to the legal and political process for protection.

With power must come accountability.

The comments to this entry are closed.