« As mayor of one town and attorney of another, Michael Pizzi carried out feds' bogus scheme | Main | “Paranoid” Pizzi and Manny “Macho” Maroño star in Miami-Dade's telenovela of sleaze »

Miami-Dade, Broward low-income schools struggle under Florida grading system

@MrMikeVasquez @NewsbySmiley

With dozens of changes in just the past three years, the formula behind Florida’s A-to-F school grading system has been criticized as a confusing mess. But there’s been at least one constant in Miami-Dade and Broward results: The wealthiest schools never get Fs, and schools with high populations of poor students face an uphill battle to even get a C.

The trend is visible through a decade-plus ofschool grade results, dating back to the first grades issued in 1999.

A Miami Herald analysis of this year’s elementary and middle school grades (high school grades aren’t available yet) shows:

•  Although high poverty rates don’t necessarily doom a school to a subpar grade, D and F schools are overwhelmingly serving students from poor neighborhoods, and the few schools that do overcome poverty to achieve an A are outliers. (There were nine such schools this year, all in Miami-Dade).

•  Of the 209 schools in Miami-Dade and Broward with at least 90 percent of students receiving free or reduced lunch, 78 percent received a grade of C or worse. Roughly 39 percent of these high-poverty schools received a D or F.

•  Of the 43 local schools with much lower poverty rates (30 percent or fewer students receiving free or reduced lunch), 86 percent received an A, and none received a D or F.

As the school reform movement that created letter grades faces a growing backlash from parents and teachers — and U.S. child poverty rates continue to rise — the income-driven distribution of the grades has prompted an uncomfortable question: Are grades measuring how well a school teaches kids, or are they simply a reflection of how much money the parents of students have?

More here.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

R. Berthaut

Report Card

Grades for our Tallahassee State Legislature:

Education Reform: C-

Healthcare Law Implementation: F

Election Reform: F

Protection of Worker and Consumer Rights: D

Right to Privacy: F

Immigration Reform: D

Corruption, Duplicity, and Hypocrisy: A-

Corporate boot-licking: A

Intransigence: A+

The comments to this entry are closed.