Critical faves Herzog & de Meuron were first out of the gate with -- it’s fair to say -- knockout preliminary designs for the new Miami Art Museum.
But London-based architect Sir Nicholas Grimshaw’s firm, no slouches in the fame department though not so well known in the USA, appears to have managed a potent counterpunch with its conceptual designs and renderings for the planned new Miami Science Museum next to MAM. (Not that it’s a contest or anything, since architects aren’t the least bit competitive.)
Check out some more images in this album. Grimshaw’s known for his knack for high-tech design. It shows through in these conceptually daring renderings, released Monday by the museum.
Here’s the story I wrote for print:
The Miami Science Museum has unveiled an ultramodern conceptual design for its planned new downtown home that wraps a series of layered outdoor terraces around a big Gulf Stream aquarium and a striking new planetarium orb overlooking Biscayne Boulevard.
Capping the three-level structure: a clear, teardrop-shaped canopy that would allow natural light to flow into the building and through the main aquarium tank -- and permit residents of the condo towers across Biscayne to look into the museum.
Crammed with digital technology, the $275 million project, scheduled to start construction late next year, is designed to function as an organic demonstration of green-building principles and South Florida's climate and ecology. Visitors would follow a spiral ramp leading indoors, then outside, then back inside, while traveling from the stars of the Cosmos down through the Florida wetlands to the bottom of the Gulf Stream.
Perhaps the most dazzling feature is the cone-shaped aquarium tank, 100 feet across at the top. The tank is sliced open at an angle at the bottom to allow visitors to peer up through the water toward the sky.
The building -- designed by the noted Grimshaw Architects of England, with aquarium design by Thinc of New York -- has been shaped to take full advantage of the local climate and landscape, museum officials say.
The structure would be largely open on two sides where it faces the planned new Museum Park on the site of the current Bicentennial Park, offering visitors unencumbered vistas of Biscayne Bay and the cruise-ship port while directing the prevailing easterly breezes through its expansive terraces. Solar energy would be collected in photovoltaic cells, and
rainwater recycled for use in the museum.
Rain would flow through the building, triggering turbines and other gadgets and mechanisms, museum officials say.
"The building, with its focus on sustainability, will be an exhibit in its own right," said museum director Gillian Thomas. "We wanted this very strong sunshine, wind and water experience."
Indoor galleries would house, among other features, the hands-on kids' exhibits for which the museum is known, traveling science shows and a satellite of the Historical Museum of Southern Florida, Thomas said. A wildlife center, like the one in the existing museum, would be set in an outdoor garden on a second-level terrace.
The new science museum would share eight acres with a new home for the Miami Art Museum, which issued its own preliminary design -- for a canopy-like structure on the bay by the superstar Swiss firm Herzog & de Meuron -- in 2007.
The release of the science museum's conceptual designs is meant in part to ramp up fundraising for the project. The museum has been earmarked for $175 million from a voter-approved county bond issue and about $2.3 million from the city of Miami. Science museum trustees have committed to raising the balance of $100 million in donations and
sponsorships, though so far just about $20 million has been pledged.
"I won't pretend this last year has been brilliant'' for fundraising, Thomas said, alluding to the economic downturn.
The museum expects the new building -- at 250,000 square feet, four times the size of the existing facility on South Miami Avenue -- will boost annual attendance from 150,000 to 600,000. The opening target is 2014.
The new facility would make the Miami Science Museum one of the very few in the country to have both an aquarium and a planetarium. The current facility does not have an aquarium.
The new planetarium would represent a marked upgrade from the existing facility, using cutting-edge multimedia technology to project distant images captured by the Hubble telescope and other sources on the overhead dome.
The egg-shaped planetarium would also function as an iconic symbol of the museum at the junction of Biscayne Boulevard and the MacArthur Causeway, said Vincent Change, partner in charge of the project at Grimshaw, which is working with local firm Rodriguez and Quiroga.
The new science museum, which would face the new MAM across a public plaza on the northern end of the existing park, responds to cues from its neighbor in the shape of a broad sheltering roof supported by skinny columns.
"Much of our building is about creating very comfortable sheltered outdoor spaces," Chang said. "It's the anthises of museums that by necessity are hermetically sealed. It's physically and thematically open."
The idea for the cascading terraces came from canyon faces in the American Southwest where rock shelves serve as sheltered habitat, Chang said. The so-called Living Core of the museum -- the spiraling route -- is designed to mimic a journey down through the canyon
layers into the earth and beneath it into a sinkhole, where a lost natural world awaits discovery, Chang said.
Have any of these architects consulted with a local structural engineer? The buildings look pretty but the concept of skinny columns supporting elevated volumes does not seem to be suitable to Miami Dade county, the only county in the entire state that would check the structural calculations required when they apply for a building permit. Unless the buildings eventually incorporate enough shearwalls on the inside, the structure shown would not be able to resist the design wind pressures that are mandated by the Florida Building Code.
Posted by: eugenio m. santiago | 09/28/2009 at 01:22 PM
Hi, Gene.
The Science Museum's Adriana Villar Marin responds to your query:
Yes, we do have a local structural engineer, Francisco Cuello, to complement Arup USA.
We also have the very experienced and local Rodriguez and Quiroga as our Executive Architects, working closely with Grimshaw Partners as we advance the design.
Posted by: Andres Viglucci | 09/28/2009 at 03:09 PM