« The bears are not what they seem | Main | Review: ''The Men Who Stare at Goats'' »

Review: ''Disney's A Christmas Carol''


Could there possibly be anything left to gain from yet another adaptation of Charles Dickens' tale about crabby old Ebenezer Scrooge and his life-changing encounter with three ghosts on Christmas Eve? In the case of Disney's A Christmas Carol, the answer is a surprising, resounding yes - at least so far as the IMAX 3D version goes.

Using the motion-capture technology from The Polar Express and Beowulf, in which the faces and movements of real actors are transformed into computer-generated cartoons, writer-director Robert Zemeckis finds eye-popping, high-tech new life in Dickens' hoary chestnut.

I don't know how spectacular the film would seem in a regular 2D theater, but when viewed on a giant screen via 3D glasses, Disney's A Christmas Carol becomes what we old-timers used to call an E-ticket ride. The astonishing depth of field and fine detail results in a picture that often imparts the vertigo and stomach-tickling free fall of a roller coaster. As the title openly states, this is definitely Disney's Christmas Carol more than Dickens'. Zemeckis, who seems to have lost all interest in live-action films - this is his third motion-capture cartoon in a row, and he's remaking Yellow Submarine next - continues to hone the technology and come up with dazzling new uses for it.


When snow falls over impossibly beautiful vistas of 19th century London, you'd swear the flakes are landing on your nose. And when Scrooge (played by Jim Carrey) is sent flying through the night sky and hangs momentarily in midair, the city lights below look like something you'd see from an airplane window. For a while, Disney's A Christmas Carol almost looks too good: The visuals are so entrancing, the creases in Scrooge's wrinkled skin so vividly rendered, you're marveling at the movie instead of watching it.

But once the ghosts come calling (all three also played by Carrey), Dickens' story grabs you all over again. Zemeckis (Forrest Gump, Contact, Back to the Future), a creator of HBO's Tales From the Crypt and a co-producer of a string of B-grade horror pictures, accentuates the scary stuff to a surprising degree. Some young children at a recent preview sounded genuinely frightened at times, and even I jumped out of my chair when Scrooge's door knocker suddenly sprang to ghostly, spooky life.


But there is also considerable wonder and charm in Disney's A Christmas Carol - the Ghost of Christmas Present, who makes his entrance sitting atop a gigantic Christmas tree made of cakes and cookies and gifts, is an awe-inspiring creation - and the story still ends in a rush of uplift and happiness, although Zemeckis resists the temptation to overdo the schmaltz. His heart really belongs to the darker side of Dickens' story, though. And Zemeckis has leavened the tale with the kind of fantastic action that might send children home wondering if Dickens didn't write the Indiana Jones pictures, too. I can't wait for the inevitable Disney World theme park ride.

Disney's A Chrismas Carol opens in South Florida on Friday, Nov. 6.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.


This is good news. I was really worried about this one.


Ebert gave this 4 stars. We are going tomorrow, I'm happy to see so many good reviews. 3D is fun!


Saw it tonight. I caught my 8-yr old daughter with her hands out before her to catch the snowflakes that seemed to be falling in our laps.

Some parts are on the edge of terrifying. My daughter says she was okay, but I could hear kids behind me really frightened, and one parent left with her 10ish yr old daughter about 3/4s through.

Visually stunning. Extremely dark. The glasses gave me a headache, but it was worth it. Dicken's story is indelibly portrayed, and the film doesn't balk at allowing Christmas to be a Christian holy day.

I thought it was impressive. I hope I don't have nightmares.


Outstanding adaptation! The computer animation gave the filmmakers to the chance to add to the horror Scrooge must have felt as he learned each lesson! Most impressive to me was the nod that the film gave to the greatest of all the Carol versions, the 1951 Alistar Simms classic "SCROOGE". The filmmakes must have loved that version as well because the dance that Carey's Scrooge with Mrs Dilber made me feel as though I was watching Simm's Scrooge again for the first time.

Four Stars!


Really dark, and really scary!!!!!! no christmas spirit at all!!!!!!!!!! Wast of money. We went to have fun, and came out with a crying kid. Thanks for nothing, Disney.

TomTom Voices

great site- thanks so much

Christmas Carols

Agree with Katia -- kinda dark. I'm a little tired of Jim Carey as well.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Copyright | About The Miami Herald | Advertise